The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Phillips' cliff fern

Plummer's cliff fern, Plummer's woodsia

Stems

compact to short-creeping, erect to horizontal, with few to many persistent petiole bases of unequal lengths;

scales mostly uniformly brown but at least some bicolored with dark central stripe and pale brown margins, narrowly lanceolate.

compact, erect to ascending, with a few persistent petiole bases of unequal lengths;

scales often uniformly brown but at least some bicolored with dark central stripe and pale brown margins, narrowly lanceolate.

Leaves

5–35 × 1.5–6 cm.

5–25 × 1.5–6 cm.

Petiole

light brown or straw-colored when mature, occasionally darker at very base, not articulate above base, relatively brittle and easily shattered.

reddish brown to dark purple when mature, not articulate above base, somewhat pliable and resistant to shattering.

Blade

lanceolate, usually 2-pinnate proximally, sparsely to moderately glandular, never viscid;

glandular hairs with thin stalks and slightly expanded tips;

rachis with scattered glandular hairs and hairlike scales.

lanceolate to ovate, usually 2-pinnate proximally, densely glandular, often somewhat viscid;

most glandular hairs with thick stalks and distinctly bulbous tips;

rachis with abundant glandular hairs and a few narrow scales.

Pinnae

elongate-deltate to elliptic, longer than wide, often attenuate to a narrowly acute apex;

largest pinnae with 7–18 pairs of widely spaced pinnules;

abaxial and adaxial surfaces somewhat glandular, lacking nonglandular hairs or scales.

ovate-deltate to elliptic, longer than wide, abruptly tapered to a rounded or broadly acute apex, occasionally attenuate;

largest pinnae with 5–11 pairs of pinnules;

abaxial and adaxial surfaces glandular, lacking nonglandular hairs or scales.

Indusia

of narrow, filamentous segments, these uniseriate for most of length, composed of ± isodiametric cells, often greatly surpassing mature sporangia.

of relatively broad segments;

segments multiseriate for most of length, often divided and uniseriate distally, composed of ± isodiametric cells, often surpassing mature sporangia.

Spores

averaging 37–44 µm. 2n = 76.

averaging 44–50 µm. 2n = 152.

Pinnules

dentate, often shallowly lobed;

margins often lustrous adaxially, somewhat thickened, with occasional glands, appearing ciliate due to presence of multicellular translucent projections on teeth that are often prolonged to form twisted filaments.

dentate, often shallowly lobed;

margins nonlustrous, thin, densely glandular, lacking cilia but with occasional 1–2-celled translucent projections.

Vein

tips usually enlarged to form whitish hydathodes visible adaxially.

tips slightly (if at all) enlarged, barely visible adaxially.

Woodsia phillipsii

Woodsia plummerae

Phenology Sporulating summer–fall. Sporulating late spring–fall.
Habitat Cliffs and rocky slopes, usually on granitic or volcanic substrates Cliffs and rocky slopes, usually on granite or volcanic substrates
Elevation 1600–3200 m (5200–10500 ft) 700–3100 m (2300–10200 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
AZ; NM; TX; n Mexico
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
AZ; CA; CO; NM; OK; TX; n Mexico
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Woodsia phillipsii traditionally has been identified as W. mexicana. It differs from typical W. mexicana, however, in having completely filamentous indusial segments, multicellular (often filamentous) translucent projections on the pinnule margins, a greater number of pinnules per pinna, and a diploid chromosome number. Woodsia phillipsii is the only diploid species currently recognized in the W. mexicana complex, and it was probably involved in the hybrid origins of both W. mexicana and W. neomexicana. Some individuals of the latter species are difficult to distinguish from W. phillipsii (see comments under W. neomexicana), and the two taxa occasionally hybridize to produce sterile triploids of intermediate morphology. Woodsia phillipsii is also known to hybridize with W. plummerae (see comments under that species) and W. cochisensis.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

The origin and phylogenetic affinities of the tetraploid Woodsia plummerae have not been established with certainty. The hypothesis that it arose as a hybrid between the Mexican species W. mollis (Kaulfuss) J. Smith and W. mexicana Fée (D. F. M. Brown 1964; D. B. Lellinger 1985) seems untenable in light of recent chromosome studies indicating that the latter species is also tetraploid (M. D. Windham 1993). On the basis of sporophyte morphology and spore ornamentation, W. plummerae appears most closely related to the W. mexicana complex and W. oregana. In fact, W. oregana can be difficult to separate from W. plummerae in western New Mexico and northern Arizona. Intermediate plants occurring in this region may represent stable allotetraploids resulting from hybridization between the diploid progenitors of W. plummerae and W. oregana subsp. cathcartiana. Considering the available evidence, populations of W. plummerae in the United States probably originated through autopolyploidy from a recently discovered, but as yet unnamed, Mexican diploid of similar morphology. Woodsia plummerae occasionally hybridizes with W. phillipsii to produce sterile, morphologically intermediate triploids.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Source FNA vol. 2. FNA vol. 2.
Parent taxa Dryopteridaceae > Woodsia Dryopteridaceae > Woodsia
Sibling taxa
W. alpina, W. cochisensis, W. glabella, W. ilvensis, W. neomexicana, W. obtusa, W. oregana, W. plummerae, W. scopulina
W. alpina, W. cochisensis, W. glabella, W. ilvensis, W. neomexicana, W. obtusa, W. oregana, W. phillipsii, W. scopulina
Synonyms W. obtusa var. glandulosa, W. obtusa var. plummerae, W. pusilla var. glandulosa
Name authority Windham: Contr. Univ. Michigan Herb. 19: 50. (1993) Lemmon: Bot. Gaz. 7: 6. (1882)
Web links