The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

brittle crisp-moss, fragile tortella moss

tortella moss

Habit Plants coarse, rigid, dark green to yellowish or blackish brown, elongate. Plants small to medium-sized, in loose or dense tufts, mats or compact sods, fragile, dull green, yellowish to dark green distally, black, brown or tan proximally with prominent shining costae.
Stem(s)

leaves firm, coarse, rigid, uniform in size and shape along the stem and apex, lowermost leaves mostly without leaf tips, leaves typically fragile only at base of deciduous apical subula, stiffly erect-appressed, incurved (or stem-apical leaves somewhat twisted around the stem when dry);

erect and weakly spreading when moist, narrowly lanceolate to linear, narrowing gradually into the distal region until contracting into a narrower propaguloid region up to 1/2 the distal leaf length; broadly to narrowly concave, keeled toward the apex in nonpropaguloid leaves, 4–6 mm;

base broadly oblong;

margins plane to erect, not to somewhat undulate;

apex narrowly acute, those of nonmodified leaves shallowly channeled to subnaviculate, not cucullate, those of modified leaves long-subulate, fragile, the subula obtusely thickened and multi-stratose distally and often broken off, youngest leaves arising from the stem apex fully propagulose and subulate;

costa short-excurrent as a smooth or weakly denticulate mucro of 1–5 rhomboidal cells, in propaguloid leaves, internal cells in section appearing undifferentiated in the subula;

adaxial surface covered by quadrate to short-rectangular, papillose laminal cells throughout the leaf except in the propaguloid leaf portion where a narrow medial groove is covered by elongate (8:1) smooth cells;

cross section lunate and broad, adaxial epidermal cells may be interrupted in the center, exposing the adaxial stereid layer by about two cells in width, in propaguloid leaves stereid layers appear undifferentiated in the subula;

proximal laminal cells rather abruptly differentiated from distal cells, yellow-hyaline, elongate, firm to laxly thin-walled, smooth;

margin with a narrow line of firm- to thin-walled cells extending a short way up the lamina or to mid-leaf;

distal laminal cells frequently 2-stratose on one or both laminae beside the costa, or equally extending toward the margins in various degrees, and becoming completely 2-stratose and ultimately undifferentiated in the, deciduous leaf tips, rounded-quadrate or hexagonal, (9–)10–12(–13) µm wide, strongly papillose, areolation more or less distinct;

marginal cells in median leaf region undifferentiated, papillose-crenulate, along the distal median margin and into the subula differentiated as one or two rows of smooth, thick-walled, short-rectangular, (4–3:1), epapillose, yellowish cells leading into the subulate region and extending to the apex distinctly visible in at least some leaves, sometimes present only in young leaves on mature stems.

leaves cirrhate-crispate to incurved when dry, spreading to recurved when moist, elongate-oblong to linear-lanceolate or linear-subulate, widest at or near the base;

base hyaline, oblong, erect;

margins plane to incurved distally, generally entire and minutely crenulate by projecting papillae, but often slightly or irregularly scalloped by indentations at points of laminal weakness, occasionally somewhat to strongly undulate, rarely with a border of elongate, clear, smooth cells in one series beyond midleaf, gradually tapering distally or more or less abruptly narrowed;

apex acute or obtuse, cucullate or concave, with an apiculus, mucro or short subula;

costa strong, percurrent to short-excurrent, adaxial and abaxial epidermal cells often present, often interrupted, adaxial and abaxial stereid bands and 1 layer of median guide cells present, hydroid strand occasionally present;

proximal cells enlarged, laxly long-rectangular, thin-walled, hyaline, occasionally brown and rather thick-walled, smooth, abruptly differentiated from the green cells distally or gradual in transition, limit of the proximal region usually appears as a V, sometimes a U, often extending distally up each leaf margin as a short or elongated border;

distal laminal cells medially and distally rounded-hexagonal, chlorophyllose, frequently obscured by numerous, dense, C-shaped papillae on both surfaces.

Seta

1.5–2 cm, occasionally two per perichaetium.

1(–2) per perichaetium, yellow or reddish proximally with age, to 3 cm, erect, smooth.

Sexual condition

dioicous;

perigonia not seen;

perichaetial leaves setaceous, fragile, with propaguloid modifications as in stem leaves.

dioicous, occasionally autoicous;

perigonia terminal, short-foliose to gemmate or as stalked buds in leaf axils of perichaetiate plants;

perichaetia terminal, leaves not or little differentiated, or distinct and long-setaceous.

Capsule

1.8–3 mm;

annulus none or of 1–2 rows of weakly vesiculose cells, operculum ca. 1.5 mm;

peristome teeth long, spirally wound, twisted 1–3 times.

erect and symmetric or slightly inclined, yellow to reddish brown, darker red or brown at mouth, elliptic to cylindric, more or less wrinkled-plicate when dry and empty;

annulus sometimes present, of 1–4 rows of vesiculose cells, persistent;

operculum conic or long-rostrate, half as long as the urn or longer, straight or inclined;

peristome orange-red, single, with a low basal membrane, of 32 filiform rami joined at the base into 16 pairs, twisted counterclockwise or merely obliquely inclined, branched-spiculose, rarely nearly smooth.

Calyptra

cucullate, smooth.

Spores

8–12(–20) µm, yellowish brown, moderately coarsely to finely papillose to nearly smooth.

Specialized

asexual reproduction by deciduous, subulate, rigid, smooth-sided, distally thickened apices of all leaves.

asexual reproduction at the stem apex occasional, by deciduous or fragile propaguloid leaf tips, or by deterioration of fragile leaves along zones of laminal weakness.

Tortella fragilis

Tortella

Habitat Seldom fruiting, capsules mature summer (Jun). Substrates probably dessicated some of the year, acid or calcareous rock, seepage, crevices and ledges of cliffs in maritime situations, dry prairies, logs or peaty humus in springs, fens, Thuja swamps, open sands of lake shores, tundra, alpine and willow bogs, frost boils, margins of solifluction lobes, snow patch margins
Elevation low to high elevations (0-3600 m) (low to high elevations (0-11800 ft))
Distribution
from FNA
AK; CO; IA; MI; MN; MT; NC; ND; NJ; NV; NY; OR; SD; TN; VT; WA; WY; AB; BC; LB; MB; NB; NS; NT; NU; ON; QC; YT; Atlantic Islands (Iceland); Australasia; Pacific Islands (New Zealand); Greenland; Africa; Asia; Europe; Antarctica
[WildflowerSearch map]
Nearly worldwide
Discussion

The long, subulate, rigid, usually fragile leaves with propaguloid tips that are not or only slightly contorted when dry are distinctive of Tortella fragilis. In ambiguous cases, the 2-stratose cross section of the distal leaves is diagnostic, but usually all that is necessary for identification is to demonstrate the smooth, elongate, thicker-walled cells along the leaf margin near the apex. The leaves may be stiff and merely arcuate in some plants, in others variously to strongly contorted-circinate, but not crisped. Such plants may be difficult to distinguish from Tortella tortuosa var. fragilifolia, which, however, has a fragile leaf lamina in addition to fragile leaf apices

Quadrate, papillose epidermal cells across the adaxial portion of the costa occur throughout the leaf of Tortella fragilis except in the proximal cell region and in the propaguloid-setaceous part of the leaf where the costa is often exposed in a continuous groove of elongate cells. This character is useful in distinguishing the species from T. rigens, which has a continuous band of smooth, elongate cells on the adaxial surface of the costa throughout the length of the leaf.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species 53 (7 in the flora).

Trichostomum is similar to Tortella in leaf shape and margin flexion, but has distal laminal cells differentiated from the proximal cells in a line straight across the leaf base or in a low, poorly defined U shape, i.e., straight across but with some smooth, hyaline, elongated proximal cells extending up the leaf margins distal to the leaf shoulder. The proximal-cell line of differentiation usually forms a distinct V shape in Tortella. The peristomes of Trichostomum are erect, often short and frequently smooth, whereas those of Tortella are long and twisted generally 2–3 times (only slightly so in T. flavovirens) and densely spiculose in noncleistocarpous species (see R. H. Zander 1993). In much of the literature the peristomes of Tortella are described as papillose, when they are actually spiculose.

Pleurochaete does not have the V-shaped area of differentiated hyaline proximal echlorophyllose cells as with Tortella, but has a median area of gradually differentiated proximal cells and a strong border of several rows of cells contrasting with both laminal and proximal cells in being abruptly longer, thinner-walled, smooth and without chlorophyll. Pleurochaete also has perichaetia, in addition to perigonia, borne laterally on short branches on the main axis of the plant.

Species in Weissia are similar to Tortella by the incurving leaf margins (generally strongly and sharply incurved throughout the leaf length) with a tendency toward cucullation in the leaf apex. The proximal cells of some Weissia species may extend slightly up the margins, as in species of Trichostomum, and most especially, Weissia jamaicensis resembles a Tortella by a proximal region with a V shape. In the following treatment, great emphasis has been put on the cross section of the distal region of the leaf in delimiting taxa and for discussing relationships.

Excluded Species:

Tortella nitida (Lindberg) Brotherus

Tortella nitida has been ascribed to the flora area by I. M. Haring (1938) and S. Flowers (1973) among others. The specimens on which those reports were based have been suggested to be a variant of T. tortuosa by H. A. Crum and L. E. Anderson (1981), who also stated that material cited as T. nitida by Haring was in fact either T. fragilis or T. tortuosa, while material from Utah, described by Flowers, was not seen by them. A few specimens labeled T. nitida from various herbaria in North America were in fact one or the other of those two species. However, the specimens cited by Haring were variously either T. tortuosa var. fragilifolia or T. alpicola, and of the two cited for Utah by Flowers, the one available for study was T. alpicola. None of the three specimens cited by Haring was T. tortuosa or T. fragilis. Tortella nitida, a European species, has proximal cells gradually, not abruptly, differentiated from the laminal cells, a costa shining on the abaxial leaf surface with no distinctive subulate propaguloid leaf apex, and leaf cells to 10 µm wide. Its leaves are usually broadly lanceolate to almost oblong-ligulate, whereas those of all of the taxa just cited are lanceolate to linear-lanceolate. Only T. alpicola and Trichostomum tenuirostre are like it in its laminal fragility and stem central strand.

Tortella mollissima E. B. Bartram

The collection reported as Tortella mollissima by P. L. Redfearn Jr. (1969) is Trichostomum tenuirostre. R. H. Zander (1994g) has made Tortella mollissima (with a Mexican type) a synonym of Pseudosymblepharis schimperiana (Paris) H. A. Crum, a species of Mexico, Central America, and South America.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key
1. Leaves oblong-lanceolate or elliptical, apex broadly acute to obtuse, sometimes cucullate
→ 2
1. Leaves narrowly short to long- or linear-lanceolate, not cucullate or obtuse, apex narrowly acute, tapering to an acuminate point, sometimes apex very long, with a long, setaceous point
→ 5
2. Autoicous, nearly always fruiting; distal margins plane to erect, apex broadly acute; distal leaf cells about 6-7 µm; central strand present; cells on adaxial surface of the costa quadrate and papillose throughout most of its length; stems short; plants typically rosulate, densely foliose.
T. humilis
2. Dioicous, seldom fruiting; distal margins incurved to strongly or variably cucullate at the apex, apex obtuse; distal leaf cells 7-11(-14) µm; central strand present or absent; cells on adaxial surface of the costa quadrate and papillose throughout most of their length or mostly or entirely elongate and smooth; stems elongate; plants loosely foliose
→ 3
3. Stem central strand present; costa with adaxial epidermis: areas on the adaxial surface of the costa with quadrate papillose cells; leaf apex variably somewhat cucullate, acute or obtuse with apical margins incurved; leaves flat in the leaf middle, keeled distally; fertile perichaetial leaves not much differentiated; mosses exclusively of coastal North Carolina south to Florida and west to Texas.
T. flavovirens
3. Stem central strand absent; costa without adaxial epidermis: adaxial surface of the costa with smooth, elongate cells throughout the leaf length; leaf apex distinctly cucullate, occasionally acute, leaves tubulose; fertile perichaetial leaves conspicuously differentiated, with subulate tips; mosses of the Great Lakes region and north
→ 4
4. Leaf cells 11-12 µm or less, stems orange to greenish yellow-brown, leaves deep yellow or orange in KOH; leaves irregularly or uniformly twisted on the stem; leaf apices usually cucullate to narrowly acute, not deciduous; leaves in section usually keeled at the costa, margins incurved; rock crevices or unconsolidated alluvial sediments near water.
T. inclinata
4. Leaf cells averaging 14 µm; stems dark green to brown, leaves green in KOH; leaves erect, twisted only at the stem tips; leaf apices variable, usually acute to acuminate, never uniformly cucullate, frequently with a narrowed apical deciduous point; leaves in section broadly tubulose; limestone pavements with thin soil cover in the Great Lakes region.
T. rigens
5. Leaves with distinctive apical propaguloid modifications, leaf apices regularly fallen
→ 6
5. Leaves without apical propaguloid modifications although some apices may be somewhat fragile
→ 7
6. Stems 1-5 cm, coarsely tomentose; central strand absent; distal leaves to 7 mm, densely crowded, rigid, with patches of elongated, nonpapillose cells on distal leaf margins of young leaves at the stem apex; leaf cells 10-12 µm; lamina proximal to subula 2-stratose; apical propagula falling in a single rigid unit; subulate limb 2- to multistratose.
T. fragilis
6. Stems 0.5 to 1.5 cm, scarcely or not tomentose; central strand present; distal leaves 1.5-2 mm, sparse, soft, leaf tips without differentiated marginal cells; leaf cells 14 µm; lamina 1-stratose throughout; propaguloid leaves and apical propagula articulated by periodic constrictions, falling in several pieces; leaves 2-stratose only in patches or along costa distally.
T. alpicola
7. Stems with central strand, leaf cells ca. 14 µm.
T. alpicola
7. Stems without central strand, or this rare, leaf cells to 14 µm but often less
→ 8
8. Leaves tubulose, margins broadly incurved; most distal laminal cells 14 µm; quadrate, papillose adaxial cells on the surface of the costa absent throughout the leaf length to a width of two or three cells in section; leaf apices deciduous; limestone pavements in the Great Lakes region.
T. rigens
8. Leaves plane to canaliculate, margins plane to erect; distal laminal cells seldom attaining 12 µm, usually less; quadrate, papillose adaxial cells on the surface of the costa present in the median leaf region or higher; of general temperate to Arctic distribution.
T. tortuosa
Source FNA vol. 27, p. 507. FNA vol. 27, p. 498. Author: Patricia M. Eckel.
Parent taxa Pottiaceae > subfam. Trichostomoideae > Tortella Pottiaceae > subfam. Trichostomoideae
Sibling taxa
T. alpicola, T. flavovirens, T. humilis, T. inclinata, T. rigens, T. tortuosa
Subordinate taxa
T. alpicola, T. flavovirens, T. fragilis, T. humilis, T. inclinata, T. rigens, T. tortuosa
Synonyms Didymodon fragilis Mollia subg. T.
Name authority (Hooker & Wilson) Limpricht: Laubm. Deutschl. 1: 606. (1888) (Lindberg) Limpricht: Laubm. Deutschl. 1: 599. (1888)
Web links