The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

devil's-claw cactus, small flower fishhook cactus

grama-grass cactus, paper-spine cactus, paperspine fishhook cactus, toumeya

Stems

unbranched or branched near base, depressed-spheric, spheric, cylindric, or elongate-cylindric, 4.5–45 × 3.5–14.5 cm;

ribs (10–)13(–16), tubercles evident on ribs.

unbranched, cylindric or obconic cylindric, 2–7.5(–8) × 1.2–2.5 cm;

ribs not evident, tubercles prominent.

Spines

frequently obscuring stems;

radial spines 8–17 per areole, usually white, sometimes brown or purplish pink, 6–36 mm;

central spines (3–)4–6(–8) per areole, 1–5 hooked;

abaxial central spine usually purple black, hooked, 15–72 × 0.6–1 mm;

lateral spines 2–6 per areole, similar to abaxial, usually shorter, usually not hooked;

adaxial central spine usually white (rarely gray, straw colored, pink, or reddish brown), flat to angled or terete; straight (rarely contorted), 17–82(–90) × 0.7–1.5(–3) mm.

dense, obscuring stems;

radial spines 5–10 per areole, white, straight, flat, (2–)3–5 × 0.3–0.6 mm;

central spines 1(–4) per areole;

abaxial central spine 1 per areole, whitish to tan or gray, straight, wavy, twisting, or curling, flat, flexible, papery, with obscure adaxial midrib, sometimes pointing upward and obscuring apex of plant, lacking hook, 15–45(–50) × 1–1.5 mm;

lateral or adaxial central spines 0(–3) per areole, white to tan, (3–)20–40 × 0.5–1 mm.

Flowers

funnelform to campanulate, (2–)3–5.7(–7) × 2.5–5.5(–8) cm;

outer tepals with greenish or brownish purple midstripes and rose to purple, pink, yellow, or white margins, oblanceolate, 25–50 × 6–10 mm, mucronate, margins entire;

inner tepals rose to purple, pink, or yellow (rarely white), oblanceolate, 15–55 × 6–12 mm, margins entire to fringed, apex mucronate;

filaments purple, yellow, or green;

anthers yellow;

ovary papillate, appearing granular.

funnelform to narrowly campanulate, 2–2.5 × 1–2.5 cm;

outer tepals with green-purple to red-brown midstripes and cream to white margins, cuneate-spatulate, usually 9–20 × 1–3 mm, finely toothed;

inner tepals white with brown midstripes, largest tepals oblanceolate, 15–20 × 3.5–4.5 mm, apex acute to mucronate;

filaments white to greenish yellow;

anthers cream to pale yellow.

Fruits

irregularly dehiscent, green turning reddish pink, 10–30 × 10–15 mm;

scales few, membranous fringed.

indehiscent or irregularly dehiscent, green, subspheric, 4–6 × 3–5 mm, dry at maturity;

scales few or none.

Seeds

dark brown to black, 2.5–3.5 × 1.5–3 mm;

testa with rounded papillae.

black, 2.5–3 × 2–2.5 mm, shiny;

testa with fine, rounded papillae.

Sclerocactus parviflorus

Sclerocactus papyracanthus

Phenology Flowering late Apr–May. Flowering Apr–Jun.
Habitat Sandy, gravelly, or clay hills, mesas, and washes, desert grasslands or saltbush, sagebrush, rabbitbrush, and blackbrush communities, pinyon-juniper woodlands Desert grasslands, pinyon-juniper woodlands, Chihuahuan desert scrub
Elevation 1000-2100 m (3300-6900 ft) 1500-2200 m (4900-7200 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
AZ; CO; NM; UT
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
AZ; NM; TX
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Sclerocactus parviflorus has an extensive range and great morphologic variation. Many named segregates have been proposed (L. D. Benson 1982; K. D. Heil and J. M. Porter 1994; F. Hochstätter 1995b) and some of these clearly merit recognition at the subspecific or varietal level. However, we are not attempting to subdivide this very complex group. Considerable work remains in understanding morphologic diversification within this species.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

With long, flexuous, flattened spines and pale flowers, Sclerocactus papyracanthus is surprisingly cryptic in the field. There has been a long debate concerning its taxonomic placement. Chloroplast DNA analyses of J. M. Porter et al. (2000) unambiguously placed this species within Sclerocactus, a position first suggested based on morphologic evidence (K. D. Heil et al. 1981; C. Glass and R. A. Foster 1984).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Source FNA vol. 4, p. 202. FNA vol. 4, p. 205.
Parent taxa Cactaceae > subfam. Cactoideae > Sclerocactus Cactaceae > subfam. Cactoideae > Sclerocactus
Sibling taxa
S. blainei, S. brevispinus, S. cloverae, S. glaucus, S. mesae-verdae, S. nyensis, S. papyracanthus, S. polyancistrus, S. pubispinus, S. sileri, S. spinosior, S. wetlandicus, S. whipplei, S. wrightiae
S. blainei, S. brevispinus, S. cloverae, S. glaucus, S. mesae-verdae, S. nyensis, S. parviflorus, S. polyancistrus, S. pubispinus, S. sileri, S. spinosior, S. wetlandicus, S. whipplei, S. wrightiae
Synonyms Echinocactus parviflorus, Echinocact parviflorus var. havasupaiensis, Echinocact parviflorus var. roseus, Ferocactus parviflorus, Pediocactus parviflorus, S. contortus, S. havasupaiensis var. roseus, S. intermedius, S. parviflorus subsp. havasupaiensis, S. parviflorus var. intermedius, S. parviflorus subsp. terrae-canyonae, S. terrae-canyonae, S. whipplei var. intermedius, S. whipplei var. roseus Mammillaria papyracantha, Pediocactus papyracanthus, Toumeya papyracantha
Name authority Clover & Jotter: Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 68: 419, fig. 8. (1941) (Engelmann) N. P. Taylor: Bradleya 5: 94. (1987)
Web links