The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

bristly rose, Nootka rose, wild rose

brier, rose, rosier

Habit Shrubs, loosely clustered or forming dense thickets. Shrubs or subshrubs, 1–50(–100) dm; rhizomatous or stoloniferous.
Stems

erect or spreading, stout or lax, 4–25(–40) dm, densely or openly branched;

bark dull reddish brown, older wood with gray exfoliate, glabrous;

infrastipular prickles 0–2, erect, curved, or hooked, often flattened, stout, subulate, sometimes deltoid, (2–)3–15(–20) × 2–10(–15) mm, base glabrous, internodal prickles usually sparse or absent, smaller, mixed with aciculi, sometimes absent.

1–20, erect to spreading, arching, climbing, or procumbent, simple or branched;

bark brown, red, and gray, often exfoliating; long and short shoots present; glabrous, rarely densely puberulent to tomentose.

Leaves

(3–)5–12(–17) cm;

stipules 12–20(–28) × 3–5(–10) mm, auricles flared, 3–6(–10) mm, margins sinuate or shallowly serrate, sparsely to ± densely stipitate-glandular, surfaces glabrous, rarely pubescent, eglandular;

petiole and rachis with pricklets absent or sparse, glabrous or pubescent, sessile- or stipitate-glandular;

leaflets 5–7(–9), terminal: petiolule (3–)5–17 mm, blade ovate, elliptic, or suborbiculate, rarely cordate or oblong, (14–)20–55(–63) × (6–)10–30(–40) mm, firm, base cuneate to obtuse, margins 1–2+-serrate, teeth 8–20 per side, often broad-based 2–4 mm, acute to obtuse, eglandular or gland-tipped, apex acute or obtuse, rarely acuminate, abaxial surfaces green, glabrous or sparsely pubescent, eglandular or sessile-glandular, adaxial green, dull, glabrous.

deciduous, rarely persistent or semipersistent, cauline;

stipules present [absent], narrow, rarely broad, margins entire or serrate, sometimes pectinate, crenate, or lacinulose, rarely serrulate, undulate, or sinuate;

petiole present;

blade cordate, elliptic, lanceolate, ovate-lanceolate, oblong, obovate, oval, ovoid, orbiculate, or suborbiculate, 1–3 cm, membranous or leathery, rugose or smooth, dull or lustrous;

leaflets (3–)5–11(–13), lateral subsessile, terminal petiolulate, elliptic to obovate, ± oblong, obovate-elliptic, lanceolate-elliptic, or obovate-oblong, margins flat, serrate, crenate, or incised, surfaces glabrous, puberulent, pubescent, or tomentose, eglandular or glandular.

Inflorescences

corymbs, 1–3(–9)-flowered.

terminal usually on lateral branches, sometimes on primary stems and shoots, (1–)4–30(–50)-flowered, usually panicles, sometimes corymbs, glabrous;

bracts absent or present, (0 or)1–3(–8);

bracteoles absent.

Pedicels

erect or recurved, slender to stout, 10–20(–33) mm, glabrous, eglandular or sparsely stipitate-glandular;

bracts 1 or 2(or 3), ovate, 13–20 × 4–9 mm, margins entire, surfaces glabrous, glandular or eglandular.

present.

Flowers

(3.5–)4.5–7(–8.5) cm diam.;

hypanthium globose to subglobose or ovoid, 4–10 × 5–8.5 mm, glabrous, eglandular, sometimes setose-glandular, neck (0–)0.5–1.5 × 3–6 mm;

sepals spreading, lanceolate, 14–25(–35) × (2–)3–4 mm, tip 5–10(–20) × 1–3 mm, margins entire, abaxial surfaces glabrous or slightly hairy, stipitate-glandular and sessile-glandular or eglandular;

petals single, pink to deep rose, (15–)20–32 × (15–)20–32 mm;

stamens 100;

carpels 28–58, styles exsert 1 mm beyond stylar orifice (2–2.5 mm diam.) of hypanthial disc (5 mm diam.).

rarely unisexual (dioecious in R. setigera or monoecious), 10–90(–100) mm diam.;

hypanthium 2–5(–10) mm, glabrous, puberulent, tomentose, or setose, eglandular or glandular;

sepals 5, erect or spreading to reflexed, ovate-lanceolate or lanceolate, rarely ovate-acuminate or deltate, margins entire or pinnatifid, apex acute, often prolonged tip;

petals [4]5 (sometimes numerous if “double”), pink to red, sometimes white, obovate, apex usually emarginate;

stamens 35–220, shorter than petals;

carpels usually borne on inner hypanthial walls, rarely on basal tori, styles glabrous or pilose, sometimes lanate or villous, exsert.

Fruits

(hips), 1–50, globose, ovoid-obovoid, ellipsoid, oblong, pyriform, or urceolate, 7–11(–20) diam., glabrous, glandular or eglandular;

hypanthium persistent, red or orange-red, purplish red, or purplish black, fleshy or leathery;

sepals persistent or deciduous, erect to spreading-erect.

Hips

red, orange-red, or purplish red, globose, depressed-globose, ovoid, oblong, or urceolate, (8–)10–20(–24) × 10–20(+) mm, fleshy, glabrous, sometimes setose, eglandular or glandular, neck (0–)1–2 × (4–)5–8 mm;

sepals persistent, erect, sometimes spreading.

Achenes

basiparietal, (1–)16–40, tan to dark tan, 4–6 × 2–4 mm.

x

= 7.

Rosa nutkana

Rosa

Distribution
from FNA
AK; AZ; CA; CO; ID; MT; NM; OR; UT; WA; WY; BC
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from USDA
North America; Mexico; Europe; Asia; n Africa [Introduced widely worldwide]
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Subspecies 3 (3 in the flora).

Rosa nutkana is a widespread, polymorphic, hexaploid species that occurs from coastal Alaska to northern California, and eastward in the Rocky Mountains from Montana to New Mexico (W. H. Lewis and B. Ertter 2007). Flowers and hips are usually solitary and significantly larger than in most sympatric species, and sepal tips are usually conspicuously prolonged and expanded. Eglandular and stipitate-glandular or setose hips can occur in the same population.

A presumed hybrid between subsp. nutkana (6x) and Rosa rugosa (2x) has been reported from Washington state. In Colorado, at the southeasternmost range of R. nutkana, a putative hybrid between subsp. melina and R. acicularis subsp. sayi has been recognized as R. ×engelmannii S. Watson. It is based on such intermediate characteristics as few infrastipular prickles with interspersed aciculi on distal stems and fertile branches, sparsely stipitate-glandular abaxial sepal surfaces, petioles and rachises with few pricklets, and blade margins 1- or multi-serrate.

Among the Lillooet and Thompson tribes of southwestern British Columbia, Rosa nutkana is considered of high value for use in traditional medicine (N. J. Turner 1988). They do not distinguish R. acicularis and R. woodsii from R. nutkana and use them similarly; R. gymnocarpa is distinct in name and use. Root extracts of R. nutkana, probably subsp. nutkana, were found to be active against an enteric coronavirus in antiviral screening (A. R. McCutcheon et al. 1995).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species ca. 140 (33 in the flora).

Most species of Rosa occur in the cooler parts of the northern hemisphere. Only three or four species extend south of the Tropic of Cancer in the Old World, none in the New World.

In an infrafamilial classification of the Rosaceae by D. Potter et al. (2007), Rosa is included in subfam. Rosoideae, supertribe Rosodae (no tribe). Distinctive features of Rosa include shrubby habit, concave or urn-shaped hypanthia, relatively numerous pistils, and fruits aggregated achenes (achenetum) inside fleshy hypanthia (hips).

Character states often are part of a continuum instead of being discrete. When addressed by differing taxonomic philosophies, radically different treatments of Rosa in North America have resulted. P. A. Rydberg (1918) recognized 129 native species and dozens of hybrids among them. E. W. Erlanson (1934) accepted 15 species, plus seven ecotype species and four putative hybrids based on cytogenetics, experimental hybridizations, common garden experiments, and field observations. Although no consensus treatment has been adopted by subsequent regional (for example, B. Ertter 1993e; A. Cronquist and N. H. Holmgren 1997) and national floras (for example, H. J. Scoggan 1978–1979, vol. 1) or monographic treatments (W. H. Lewis 1958, 1959, 1959b, 1962, 1965), a unifying feature has been a conservative approach to Rosa taxonomy, with relatively few species recognized (Ertter and Lewis 2008). Caution is advised in relying on names in synonymy for updating the identification of old collections; synonymy given here often differs from previous applications.

The approach of R. Elven et al. (1999) is followed here in using subspecies as the main infraspecific rank. The rank of variety also is used, either within subspecies or as subunits of species.

The following summary describes the methods of obtaining data. Information on introduced species was obtained chiefly from North American plants with only supplemental use of specimens from Eurasia.

Prickles, including aciculi, of all Rosa are epidermal outgrowths of stems and not thorns, which are modified stems. Acicular prickles are shaped like aciculi, needle-shaped and relatively short. Declining prickles are retrorse, being turned inward toward the axis. Infrastipular prickles are proximal to stipules, single or paired in contrast to internodal. Setaceous prickles are shaped like bristles or stiff hairs (setae). Pricklets are miniature prickles on petioles and rachises closely resembling infrastipular/internodal prickles found on stems except that they are smaller.

Herbarium specimens often do not have information on plant height, habit, or bark; field research and observations in gardens have helped provide information for these and other characters. First-year rhizomatous shoots (suckers, turions) are densely covered with mixed internodal prickles and aciculi; leaves of these often develop an extra pair of lateral leaflets when compared to older stems. Identifications using these shoots are difficult because specific differentiation at an early stage of development is limited; no attempt was made to incorporate such data in this treatment. Whenever possible, first-year rhizomatous shoots should be collected, particularly if they flower the first year, as Rosa arkansana, or when mowing or otherwise broken shoots stimulate early flowering. Data for prickles and aciculi were obtained using distal stems and distal, usually fertile branches at roughly the third or fourth internode from branch tips; measurements of infrastipular prickles (or, if none, internodal) consisted of prickle lengths to base × base lengths; relatively few aciculi or setae were measured. Leaves: stipules were measured for length of adnation to petioles, width across both sides of petioles near distal regions, and length of distally free auricles on one side. Petioles and rachises often have pricklets resembling main prickles of stems. Terminal leaflet measurements of serrations per side exclude terminal serration, and for double- or multi-serrations only each main serration is counted. Inflorescences include measurements of pedicel lengths; pedicels are slender to stout, usually varying between 0.5–1 mm diam. Flowers: sepal base width measurements at junctures with hypanthia were made of the three outer sepals; sepal margins are characteristically tomentose or pubescent and are not described (varying glandularity is), nor are induments of sepal adaxial surfaces (also tomentose or pubescent); petal numbers are either single and five or double and ten or more; available stamen number averages are from E. W. Erlanson (1934). Achenes are bony walled, round or angular (not in descriptions unless different); when unusually small, shriveled, or darkened, they are considered abortive and, if counted, are provided separately from fertile achenes. Cytology: ploidy levels obtained from flow cytometry calculations are based on nuclear DNA amounts using fresh leaflets; these are provided with the ploidy level followed by DNA only in species discussions (all research by Anne Bruneau).

When using the keys, be aware that most species known to possess prickles also have some stems and branches lacking armature.

Phenotypic variability in Rosa may be due to seasonal or annual environmental factors, varying gene expressions, hybridization, and polyploidy; in sect. Caninae, hemisexual reproduction and such features represent confounding factors in rose morphology and taxonomy.

All species of the gall-inducing cynipid wasps Diplolepis are restricted to native and introduced roses and induce structurally distinct galls. For example, in Ontario, D. polita induces a single-chambered gall on leaves of Rosa acicularis subsp. sayi; D. spinosa induces a multichambered gall on stems of R. blanda (J. D. Shorthouse 1991).

Most Rosa species have general usages, such as fleshy hips long and widely used for eating raw and as prepared foods, such as jams, jellies, and preserves, and for food supplements due to high vitamin C content. Ethnobotanical uses provided for species are based on D. E. Moerman (1998) and W. H. Lewis and M. P. F. Elvin-Lewis (2003), together with original articles and personal communications.

North American rose species have contributed modestly to the development of hybrids for the horticulture industry. Such contributions are reported in publications associated with the American Rose Society and Royal Horticultural Society (J. H. McFarland 1938; P. Harkness 2003; C. Quest-Ritson and B. Quest-Ritson 2003).

The infrageneric structure used here is relatively well established in floral and taxonomic works (with some ambivalent results from molecular analyses). The main difference is that sect. Rosa replaces the better-known sect. Cinnamomeae. This results from conservation of the type of Rosa on R. cinnamomea (J. McNeill et al. 2006, App. IIIA) over the hybrid R. ×centifolia Linnaeus in sect. Gallicae.

Two species of sect. Chinenses de Candolle ex Seringe, both cultivated in warmer areas, are reported as occasionally escaping in North America. Key distinguishing features of the section include shrubs erect or climbing, stems with curved prickles, leaflets usually 3–5 with relatively narrow, adnate stipules, sepals reflexed and deciduous after anthesis, and styles free, exsert, nearly equaling stamens. Rosa chinensis Jacquin, China rose, has been confirmed as occurring at some time in Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, South Carolina, and Virginia. The closely allied R. ×odorata (Andrews) Sweet, tea rose, was also found at some time in Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, and South Carolina, and unconfirmed in Prince Edward Island, Pennsylvania, and Utah. Rosa chinensis is distinguished from R. ×odorata by its shrubby habit (versus climbing or scrambling lianas to 20 m), leaves with 3–5(–7) leaflets (versus 5–9), stipules and auricles marginally stipitate-glandular (versus eglandular or glandular only on auricle margins), flowers usually 4 or 5, rarely solitary (versus 1–3), slightly or not fragrant (versus fragrant), 3–5 cm diam. (versus 5–10 cm diam.), with often pinnately lobed sepals (versus entire or slightly incised), and hips ovoid or pyriform (versus depressed-globose). Both species are of major importance in breeding new garden roses, especially the hybrid teas, by incorporating continuous flowering into roses.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key
1. Stems 4–10(–15) dm, internodes 2–2.5 cm; prickles (fertile branches) usually curved or hooked, rarely erect, rarely absent; sepal abaxial surfaces sessile- or stipitate-glandular; 2500–3800 m, s Rocky Mountains to Wasatch Mountains.
subsp. melina
1. Stems (6–)10–30(–40) dm, internodes 2–6.5 cm; prickles (fertile branches) erect, rarely curved, sometimes absent; sepal abaxial surfaces stipitate-glandular or eglandular; 0–2300 m, coast to n Rocky Mountains
→ 2
2. Shrubs densely branched; internodes 2–4 cm; infrastipular prickles rarely absent; terminal leaflets abaxially glandular or eglandular, margins usually 2+-serrate, teeth gland-tipped; Alaska to n California w of Cascade Mountains.
subsp. nutkana
2. Shrubs openly branched; internodes 5–6.5 cm; infrastipular prickles usually absent; terminal leaflets abaxially usually eglandular, margins 1-serrate, teeth eglandular; e Cascade Mountains to n Rocky Mountains.
subsp. macdougalii
1. Styles: hypanthial discs absent; leaves 1.5–3 cm, leaflet margins deeply incised, broadly crenate, sometimes serrate, terminal petiolules 0.5–4 mm; s California to w Texas [7a. Rosa subg. Hesperhodos].
sect. Minutifoliae
1. Styles: hypanthial discs present; leaves (2.5–)3.5–15(–18) cm, leaflet margins usually serrate, rarely deeply incised or broadly crenate, terminal petiolules (1–)5–20(–40) mm; throughout North America [7b. Rosa subg. Rosa]
→ 2
2. Stipules ± free from petioles or adnate at bases; petals white, rarely rose; leaves persistent or semipersistent, leathery
→ 3
2. Stipules adnate to petioles; petals rose to pink or white, rarely crimson; leaves deciduous, rarely semipersistent or persistent, membranous, sometimes leathery
→ 4
3. Bracts 6–8 (covering 1/2 or all of hypanthia), margins deeply laciniate; pedicels 3–6 mm, densely white sericeo-tomentose, setae dense; leaflets (5–)7–9(–11), terminal petiolules 3–5 mm, blades 14–30 × 5–15 mm.
sect. Bracteatae
3. Bracts 1(or 2), margins serrate; pedicels 12–30 mm, glabrous, setae apical or absent; leaflets 3(–5), terminal petiolules 9–13 mm, blades 40–65 × 30–40 mm.
sect. Laevigatae
4. Styles connate (exsert 3–6 mm), hypanthial discs conic; shrubs stoloniferous; stipule margins pinnatifid or lacinulose, sometimes entire; hips usually globose, 4–10 × 5–9 mm.
sect. Systylae
4. Styles free (exsert 0.5–4 mm in sect. Rosa), hypanthial discs conic or flat; shrubs rhizomatous, rhizomes sometimes absent; stipule margins usually entire, slightly crenate, or serrate; hips varying in shape, 6–18(–24) × 5–22(–25) mm
→ 5
5. Rhizomes absent or relatively short; stems erect, arching, or spreading; leaflets adaxially usually tomentulose or pubescent.
Rosa sect. Caninae
5. Rhizomes relatively long; stems erect, sometimes arching; leaflets adaxially usually glabrous
→ 6
6. Distal branches: infrastipular prickles usually present, internodal prickles sometimes intermixed with aciculi, rarely absent; pedicel bracts persistent.
sect. Rosa
6. Distal branches: infrastipular prickles usually absent, rarely present (in sect. Gallicae), internodal prickles usually intermixed with aciculi; pedicel bracts caducous or absent
→ 7
7. Leaflets 3–5(–7), terminal petiolules 6–8 mm; flowers 6–9 cm diam.; inflorescences 1–3(–8)-flowered; pedicel bracts caducous; hips bright to dark red; hypanthial discs conic, 4–5 mm diam.; sepals of hips deciduous, erect to reflexed.
sect. Gallicae
7. Leaflets (5–)9–11(–13), terminal petiolules 2–4 mm; flowers 2–4 cm diam.; inflorescences 1-flowered; pedicel bracts absent; hips blackish purple; hypanthial discs flat, 4–4.5 mm diam.; sepals of hips persistent, erect.
sect. Pimpinellifoliae
Source FNA vol. 9, p. 112. FNA vol. 9, p. 75. Authors: Walter H. Lewis, Barbara Ertter, Anne Bruneau.
Parent taxa Rosaceae > subfam. Rosoideae > tribe Roseae > Rosa > subg. Rosa > sect. Rosa Rosaceae > subfam. Rosoideae > tribe Roseae
Sibling taxa
R. acicularis, R. arkansana, R. blanda, R. bracteata, R. bridgesii, R. californica, R. canina, R. carolina, R. cinnamomea, R. foliolosa, R. gallica, R. glauca, R. gymnocarpa, R. laevigata, R. lucieae, R. minutifolia, R. mollis, R. multiflora, R. nitida, R. palustris, R. pinetorum, R. pisocarpa, R. rubiginosa, R. rugosa, R. setigera, R. sherardii, R. spinosissima, R. spithamea, R. stellata, R. tomentosa, R. virginiana, R. woodsii
Subordinate taxa
R. nutkana subsp. macdougalii, R. nutkana subsp. melina, R. nutkana subsp. nutkana
R. sect. Bracteatae, R. sect. Gallicae, R. sect. Laevigatae, R. sect. Minutifoliae, R. sect. Pimpinellifoliae, R. sect. Rosa, R. sect. Systylae
Name authority C. Presl: Abh. Königl. Böhm. Ges. Wiss., ser. 5, 6: 563. (1851) Linnaeus: Sp. Pl. 1: 491. (1753): Gen. Pl. ed. 5, 217. (1754)
Web links