The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

butterweed, cankerweed, gall-of-the-earth, lion's-foot

cankerweed, gall-of-the-earth, prenanthe, rattlesnakeroot

Habit Plants 50–200+ cm; taproots short and thick, with lateral storage roots. Perennials, 5–250 cm; taprooted, often producing offshoots connected by slender rhizomes.
Stems

erect, green to reddish or purple mottled, proximally glabrous, distally sparsely tomentulose.

1–5, usually erect, sometimes decumbent (P. bootii), usually simple (leafy), usually glabrous proximally, tomentulose distally.

Leaves

proximal often withered by flowering; petiolate (petioles 1–10 cm, often with pair of lobes);

blades deltate to ovate or elliptic, 5–20 × 4–10 cm, coriaceous, margins usually deeply, pinnately 3–5-lobed, lobes and sinuses large and ± rounded, sometimes deeply cleft to base or palmately divided, apices acute or obtuse, ultimate margins entire or dentate, faces glabrous or finely tomentose on veins;

cauline sessile or petiolate;

distal reduced in size and lobing, often entire.

basal and cauline; petiolate or sessile;

blades deltate to triangular, or ovate to oblanceolate, or oblong to linear, or spatulate, margins often pinnately or palmately lobed (sometimes deeply cleft and appearing compound), ultimate margins entire or coarsely serrate or dentate (apices acute, obtuse, or rounded);

distal leaves reduced in size and lobing.

Peduncles

not inflated distally, bracteate.

Involucres

cylindric (often attenuate basally to bracteate peduncles), 12–15 × 4–5 mm.

narrowly cylindric to campanulate (bases often attenuate), 2–14 mm diam.

Receptacles

slightly convex, smooth, glabrous, epaleate.

Florets

(8–)10–14(–19);

corollas usually yellow to pale yellow, 9–15 mm.

4–38;

corollas usually creamy white, pink, or lavender, rarely yellow or red (glabrous).

Phyllaries

(7–)8–(10), green or often purple, narrowly lanceolate to elliptic, 10–13 mm, sparsely hispid to appressed, coarsely setose, often reduced to single coarse, appressed seta (setae green or tan).

3–15 in 1 series, (yellow green or green to purple or blackish) subulate or linear to lanceolate or elliptic, equal, margins scarious, apices acute, faces glabrous, tomentulose, hispid, or coarsely setose.

Calyculi

of 8–10, green to purple, triangular to subulate bractlets 1–4 mm, often tomentulose to setose.

of 2–12, triangular to linear-lanceolate or subulate, unequal bractlets.

Heads

(6–12 in nodding clusters) in broad, paniculiform to corymbiform arrays (often widely branching and subdichotomous, at least some branches elongate).

(usually nodding at flowering) in racemiform, paniculiform, thyrsiform, or corymbiform arrays.

Cypselae

golden brown to light tan, subcylindric, subterete or angled, 5–8 mm, indistinctly 8–10-ribbed;

pappi tan, 7–8 mm.

golden brown to light tan, narrowly subcylindric, or fusiform to oblanceoloid, or oblong to linear, subterete or angled, apices truncate, not beaked, faces finely 5–12-ribbed, usually glabrous;

pappi persistent, of 30–50, dull white to yellow or tan, rarely reddish brown, ± equal, barbellulate bristles in 1 series.

x

= 8.

2n

= 16.

Prenanthes serpentaria

Prenanthes

Phenology Flowering Aug–Oct.
Habitat Oak-hickory woodlands, borders, oak flats, pine woods, sandy areas
Elevation 100–1700 m (300–5600 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
AL; CT; DC; DE; FL; GA; KY; MA; MD; MS; NC; NJ; NY; OH; PA; RI; SC; TN; VA; WV
[WildflowerSearch map]
from USDA
North America; n Asia; sc Africa (1 species)
Discussion

Prenanthes serpentaria is generally recognized by its large, deeply 3–5-lobed proximal leaves with rounded sinuses and lobes, winged petioles, attenuate involucres, sparsely setose phyllaries, and yellow corollas. The leaves are variable in size and lobing, often on the same plant. Some specimens have predominantly ovate to elliptic, unlobed leaves, and these have been variously recognized. Some specimens appear to combine characteristics of P. crepidinea or P. trifoliolata and may be the result of recent or ancient hybridization. The species boundaries in this group merit further study.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species ca. 26–30 (14 in the flora).

Prenanthes is recognized by the erect and simple habit, deeply divided proximal leaves, whitish, yellow, or pinkish corollas in nodding heads, calyculate involucres, and pappi of barbellulate bristles. Leaf shape, size, and degree of lobing are often used for distinguishing species but are sometimes exceptionally variable. The proximal leaves are usually different in size, shape, and lobing from the distal leaves. Other taxonomic characters include size and habit, corolla color, number of florets per head, and phyllary number, color, and indument. The cypselae and pappi tend to be uniform.

Molecular ITS studies by S. C. Kim et al. (1996) suggested that Prenanthes, as here circumscribed, may be polyphyletic; additional sampling including North American taxa is needed to confirm the relationships of Prenanthes and recognition of Nabalus Cassini at the genus level.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key
1. Phyllaries glabrous
→ 2
1. Phyllaries tomentulose, hispid, or coarsely setose
→ 7
2. Florets and phyllaries (4–)5(–6)
P. altissima
2. Florets and phyllaries 6–20
→ 3
3. Heads in elongate, slender, spikelike, narrowly racemiform arrays; proximal leaves oblong to linear, pinnately lobed, lobes narrow and at right angles; corollas pinkish.
P. autumnalis
3. Heads in racemiform, paniculiform, or narrowly thyrsiform arrays; proximal leaves ovate to deltate, palmately lobed, irregularly dentate or entire; corollas whitish, pinkish, or pale yellow
→ 4
4. Phyllaries ± purplish or maroon (dark on old specimens); corollas whitish to pinkish; pappi usually reddish brown (rarely yellowish)
P. alba
4. Phyllaries green to tan, dark green, or blackish; corollas white or pale yellow; pappi pale yellow
→ 5
5. Proximal leaves palmately 3(–5)-lobed (often deeply cleft, compound, lobes lanceolate, sinuses angular); involucres campanulate (attenuate at bases); calyculus bractlets triangular; corollas pale yellow
P. trifoliolata
5. Proximal leaves entire or shallowly lobed (bases hastate or sagittate to truncate or rounded); involucres cylindro-campanulate or narrowly campanulate (rounded, not attentuate at bases); calyculus bractlets subulate to narrowly lanceolate; corollas white
→ 6
6. Plants 5–25 cm; stems decumbent; alpine regions, n Appalachians.
P. boottii
6. Plants 8–75 cm; stems erect; n Rocky Mountains
P. sagittata
7. Proximal leaves petiolate, petioles ± winged, blades spatulate, usually unlobed, apices usually rounded or obtuse; mid cauline leaves sessile, often clasping; heads ± ascending
→ 8
7. Proximal leaves petiolate, petioles winged, blades deltate or triangular to elliptic or ovate (not spatulate), sometimes lobed, apices acute or obtuse; mid cauline leaves sessile or petiolate; heads nodding
→ 9
8. Midstems roughly hispid or coarsely setose; proximalmost leaves withered or deciduous by flowering; leaves ± hispid abaxially; corollas pale yellow to creamy white
P. aspera
8. Midstems glabrous; proximalmost leaves persistent to flowering; leaves glabrous; corollas usually pinkish (sometimes white or lavender)
P. racemosa
9. Proximal leaves sagittate, lobed; phyllaries hispid or tomentulose
→ 10
9. Proximal leaves deltate, ovate, or elliptic, lobed or unlobed; phyllaries coarsely setose
→ 11
10. Plants 80–150 cm; proximal leaves sagittate, bases sagittate; phyllaries hispid along midveins; Edwards Plateau, Texas
P. carrii
10. Plants 15–80 cm; proximal leaves triangular or irregularly elliptic, bases truncate or hastate; phyllaries finely tomentulose; Pacific Northwest to Alaska
P. alata
11. Proximal leaves deltate, ovate, or hastate, margins entire or coarsely serrate; phyllaries (9–)12–15, dark green to blackish; florets 15–38
P. crepidinea
11. Proximal leaves deltate to ovate or elliptic, margins palmately or pinnately lobed or unlobed, dentate or entire; phyllaries 5–10, green or purple to lavender; florets 5–15
→ 12
12. Proximal leaves coarsely dentate or serrate (unlobed); phyllaries purple or lavender
P. barbata
12. Proximal leaves 3–5-lobed; phyllaries usually green (sometimes purple in P. serpentaria)
→ 13
13. Leaves about twice as long as wide, pinnately lobed, lobes and sinuses rounded; heads in broad paniculiform or corymbiform arrays, at least some branches elongate; phyllaries green or often purple, with appressed, green or tan, coarse setae, sometimes reduced to a single seta per phyllary; florets 8–14; widespread in e, s United States.
P. serpentaria
13. Leaves about as long as wide, palmately lobed, lobes angular; heads and sinuses angular; heads in narrow paniculiform or thyrsiform arrays, branches short; phyllaries dark green, with erect, coarse setae; florets 5–7(–13); mid to high elevations in Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia
P. roanensis
Source FNA vol. 19, p. 270. FNA vol. 19, p. 264. Author: David J. Bogler.
Parent taxa Asteraceae > tribe Cichorieae > Prenanthes Asteraceae > tribe Cichorieae
Sibling taxa
P. alata, P. alba, P. altissima, P. aspera, P. autumnalis, P. barbata, P. boottii, P. carrii, P. crepidinea, P. racemosa, P. roanensis, P. sagittata, P. trifoliolata
Subordinate taxa
P. alata, P. alba, P. altissima, P. aspera, P. autumnalis, P. barbata, P. boottii, P. carrii, P. crepidinea, P. racemosa, P. roanensis, P. sagittata, P. serpentaria, P. trifoliolata
Synonyms Nabalus fraseri, Nabalus integrifolius, Nabalus serpentarius, P. integrifolia
Name authority Pursh: Fl. Amer. Sept. 2: 499, plate 24. (1813) Linnaeus: Sp. Pl. 2: 797. (1753): Gen. Pl. ed. 5, 349. (1754)
Web links