The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Chinese apple, pear-leaf crab apple, plum-leaf crabapple

Japanese or Toringo or Siebold crabapple, Toringo crab

Habit Trees, 30–80(–100) dm. Trees, sometimes shrubs, 30–80(–100) dm.
Stems

5–20 cm diam.;

bark purplish brown or gray-brown, peeling irregularly;

young branches purplish brown and densely puberulous, becoming grayish purple or grayish brown and glabrous at maturity; flowering shoots producing spurs, (5–)10–20(–35) mm.

to 30 cm diam.;

bark purplish brown, smooth, split irregularly when old;

young branches orangish brown and puberulent, becoming dark purple or purplish brown and glabrous; flowering shoots developing as spurs, rarely as thorns, (5–)15–20(–35) mm.

Buds

purplish brown, ovoid, 5–7 mm, scale margins sparsely pubescent.

purplish brown, ovoid, 20–30 mm, glabrous or only terminal scale margins puberulous.

Leaves

convolute in bud;

isomorphic;

stipules deciduous, lanceolate, 4–5 mm, apex acuminate;

petiole 10–50 mm, tomentose;

blade elliptic or ovate, (3.5–)5–9.5(–11) × (2–)4–5(–8) cm, base broadly cuneate, margins unlobed, acutely serrate or serrulate, sometimes doubly serrate, apex acuminate or acute, sometimes cuspidate, abaxial surface glabrous, adaxial puberulent or subglabrous.

conduplicate in bud;

isomorphic;

stipules deciduous, lanceolate, 4–6 mm, apex acute or acuminate;

petiole 10–25 mm, puberulous;

blade narrowly elliptic, elliptic, or ovate, 3–7 × 2–4 cm, base broadly cuneate or rounded, margins usually 3-lobed, serrate, apex acute, abaxial surface puberulous when young, veins puberulous at maturity, adaxial glabrous.

Panicles

umbel-like;

peduncles 0–2 mm;

bracteoles deciduous, rare, ± middle of pedicel, filiform, 3–4 mm.

umbel-like;

peduncles absent;

bracteoles deciduous, filiform, 4–5 mm.

Pedicels

20–35 mm, puberulous.

20–25 mm, pubescent or subglabrous.

Flowers

(30–)40–50 mm diam.;

hypanthium puberulent;

sepals triangular-lanceolate or lanceolate, 7–9 mm, longer than tube, apex acuminate, surfaces puberulent;

petals white, obovate or elliptic, 25–30 mm, claws 1–2 mm, margins entire, apex rounded;

stamens ca. 20, 8–10 mm, anthers yellow before dehiscence;

styles 4 or 5, basally connate 1/3 length, 9–11 mm, longer than stamens, proximally tomentose.

20–30 mm diam.;

hypanthium subglabrous or pubescent;

sepals lanceolate, 6–9 mm, to 2 times as long as tube, apex caudate-acuminate, abaxial surface glabrous, adaxial tomentose;

petals white, sometimes pink-white, elliptic-obovate, 15–18 mm, claws 1–2 mm, margins entire, sometimes crenulate, apex rounded;

stamens 20, 7–9 mm, anthers yellow before dehiscence;

styles 3 or 4(or 5), basally connate to 1/2 length, 8–10 mm, slightly longer than stamens, proximally villous or lanate.

Pomes

yellow to dark red, ovoid or oblong, 20–25(–34) mm diam., cores enclosed at apex;

sepals persistent, reflexed (erect), raised, swollen at base;

sclereids sparse surrounding core.

red or brownish yellow, subglobose, 6–8(–10) mm diam., cores enclosed at apex;

sepals deciduous;

sclereids absent or relatively few surrounding core.

Seeds

dark brown.

reddish brown.

2n

= 34, 51.

= 34, 51.

Malus prunifolia

Malus toringo

Phenology Flowering Apr–Jun; fruiting Aug–Oct. Flowering Apr–Jun; fruiting Aug–Sep.
Habitat Hillsides, flats Slopes, mixed forests, or shrublands
Elevation 0–1300 m (0–4300 ft) 100–2000 m (300–6600 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
CT; DC; IL; MA; ME; MN; NH; NY; PA; RI; SC; TN; VA; VT; WA; WI; NB; NS; ne Asia [Introduced in North America]
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
IL; KS; MA; MD; NY; OH; OR; PA; VA; WA; WI; ON; Asia [Introduced in North America]
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Malus prunifolia is closely related to the cultivated apple, M. pumila, and sometimes is used as rootstock for the latter because of its extensive root system. Malus prunifolia differs from M. pumila in having more sharply serrate leaves, glabrate or glabrous abaxial surfaces of mature leaves, relatively long pedicels, and pomes with raised, swollen, fleshy-based sepals.

Malus prunifolia is cultivated worldwide and utilized as grafting rootstock, as a fruit tree, and as an ornamental. The species is potentially a genetic source of cold tolerance and disease resistance for apple-breeding programs. See discussion under 4. M. fusca for distinguishing M. prunifolia from the hybrid M. ×dawsoniana.

Malus ×scheideckeri Späth ex Zabel is considered a hybrid of M. floribunda and M. prunifolia (see discussion of the latter under 8. M. halliana). The 'Scheidecker crabapple' is cultivated as an ornamental tree for its semidouble pale pink flowers and yellow to orange globose pomes.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Malus toringo is possibly naturalized in Europe.

Variety sargentii (Rehder) Asami is distinguished by its horizontally spreading branches, pure white, suborbiculate petals, and dark red fruits with a slight bloom; var. zumi (Matsumara) Asami is recognized by its ascending and spreading branches (Asami).

Malus ×zumi (Matsumura) Rehder has been reported for Ohio. The hybrid is morphologically similar to M. toringo, but differs by its larger flowers and fruits and the vigorous shoot having sparsely distributed, only slightly lobed leaves. It has been considered by some to be a variety of M. toringo and by others to be a hybrid between M. baccata and M. toringo.

Malus sieboldii Rehder and Pyrus sieboldii Regel are illegitimate names that pertain here.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Source FNA vol. 9, p. 477. FNA vol. 9, p. 479.
Parent taxa Rosaceae > subfam. Amygdaloideae > tribe Maleae > Malus Rosaceae > subfam. Amygdaloideae > tribe Maleae > Malus
Sibling taxa
M. angustifolia, M. baccata, M. coronaria, M. fusca, M. halliana, M. hupehensis, M. ioensis, M. pumila, M. toringo
M. angustifolia, M. baccata, M. coronaria, M. fusca, M. halliana, M. hupehensis, M. ioensis, M. prunifolia, M. pumila
Synonyms Pyrus prunifolia Sorbus toringo, Crataegus cavaleriei, C. taquetii, M. baccata subsp. toringo, M. sargentii, Photinia rubrolutea, Pyrus esquirolii, P. subcrataegifolia, P. toringo
Name authority (Willdenow) Borkhausen: Theor. Prakt. Handb. Forstbot. 2: 1278. (1803) (Siebold) Siebold ex de Vriese: Tuinb.-fl. 3: 368. (1856)
Web links