Flora of North America species comparison

The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Erythronium citrinum

Erythronium
Erythronium citrinum

citrus fawn lily, cream fawn lily, lemon color fawn lily, lemon fawn lily, pale fawn-lily

Adder's-tongue, dog's-tooth-violet, dogtooth-violet, fawn-lily, glacier-lily, trout-lily, érythrone
Habit Herbs, perennial, scapose, from ovate to elongate bulbs, sometimes with small, beadlike segments of short, persistent rhizome attached; several species producing additional bulbs as sessile bulbels or at the ends of slender stolons or vertical droppers, these species typically flowering more sparingly than those without extensive vegetative reproduction.
Bulbs

slender, 40–50 mm, sometimes producing sessile offsets.

Leaves

9–15 cm;

blade mottled with irregular streaks of brown or white, lanceolate to narrowly ovate, margins ± wavy.

2 (1 in nonflowering plants), basal, ± petiolate;

blade green or mottled with purple, brown, or white, lanceolate to ovate (wider if solitary), flat to folded, 6–60 cm, glaucous in a few species, glabrous, base narrowed gradually or abruptly to petiole, margins entire or sometimes wavy.
Scape

12–35 cm.

green or sometimes reddish, typically elongating in fruit.
Inflorescences

1–3-flowered.

terminal, racemose, 1–10-flowered.
Flowers

tepals ± white, often pinkish, usually pale yellow at base, lanceolate to narrowly elliptic, 25–45 mm, inner with or without small auricles at base;

stamens 11–17 mm;

filaments linear, white or pinkish, slender, less than 0.8 mm wide;

anthers white, cream, pink, reddish, or brownish red;

style straight, white or pink, 6–10 mm;

stigma unlobed or with lobes shorter than 1 mm.

showy, usually nodding, sometimes held laterally or erect;

tepals 6 (as few as 4 in E. propullans), spreading to reflexed, distinct, similar, white, yellow, pink, or violet, often with basal zone of yellow or other colors, lanceolate to ovate, inner tepals auriculate at base in many species, auricles appressed to ovary and forming sac- or pocketlike hollows on adaxial surfaces;

stamens 6;

filaments generally slender;

ovary superior;

style 1, abruptly attached to ovary (or forming a beak in E. rostratum);

stigma unlobed or 3-lobed, lobes recurved to erect. Fruits capsular, erect, obovoid to oblong, apex rounded, truncate, or umbilicate (beaked in E. rostratum), dehiscence loculicidal.
Capsules

obovoid, 2–5 cm.

Seeds

brown, ± angular, ± ovoid.
x

= 11, 12.
2n

= 24.

Erythronium citrinum

Erythronium
Phenology Flowering spring (Mar–May).
Habitat Dry woods, brushy slopes, common on serpentine substrates
Elevation 100–1300 (–1800) m (300–4300 (–5900) ft)
Distribution
from FNA
CA; OR
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from USDA
All North American; except for the Eurasian Erythronium dens-canis Linnaeus and its segregates E caucasicum Woronow; E japonicum Decaisne; and E sibiricum (Fischer & C A Meyer) Krylov; north temperate in forest and montane meadow habitats; one species (E mesochoreum) in prairies
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Plants lacking auricles on inner tepals are sometimes segregated as Erythronium howellii, Howell’s fawn-lily, but they do not appear to differ from typical E. citrinum in any other characters. Erythronium citrinum intergrades with E. californicum and E. hendersonii, occasional populations or individuals displaying intermediate or recombined characteristics. Such plants from the upper Scott River drainage in Trinity County, California, which may be the result of introgression with E. hendersonii, have been recognized as variety roderickii.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species ca. 27 (23 in the flora).

Erythronium is a well-marked and distinctive genus closely related to Tulipa. In North America, Erythronium consists of distinct eastern and western groups, the former clearly having an affinity with species of the Old World. Most of the species have attractive and showy flowers, and several are well suited for naturalizing in woodland gardens.

Pressed specimens tend to fade, so leaf and flower colors and markings should be recorded on specimen labels at the time of collection. The orientation of flowers and fruits should also be recorded, and it is useful to collect bulbs of both flowering and nonflowering plants when this will not damage a population. Bulbs of Erythronium species are often more than 10 cm deep. Collectors should press flowers so that the shape of the style, stigmas, filaments, and petal bases can be observed later.

Species of western North America (Rocky Mountains westward) and eastern North America (Great Plains eastward) seem to form two discrete evolutionary groups, and this geographic distinction is the first character used in the taxonomic key. Most western species can at least occasionally produce plants with multiple-flowered scapes, while eastern species always have a single flower. Bulbs of western species vary from ovoid to slender and elongate, while all eastern species have ovoid bulbs. Fruits of western species vary from obovoid to narrowly oblong, while all eastern species have obovoid fruits. In species with mottled leaves, the pattern of mottling in eastern species is a more or less random dappling (resembling that of the Eurasian Erythronium dens-canis), while in western species it takes the form of elongate lateral streaks or veining, often more or less symmetrical on either side of the midline. Several eastern species, but only a single western species (E. multiscapideum), propagate vegetatively by stolons originating largely from nonflowering bulbs. (The term “stolon” is used here to refer to the slender, white, elongate, underground structures found in Erythronium.) In E. propullans, one stolon per plant is produced from the flowering scape below ground level. In species with stolons, populations often contain relatively few flowering plants. In the following descriptions, measurements of bulbs and leaves refer to flowering plants.

The base chromosome number in Erythronium is x = 12, except for the white-flowered species of eastern North America, E. albidum, E. mesochoreum, and E. propullans, which have x = 11. Both diploid and tetraploid species occur with each base chromosome number (2n = 22, 24, 44, and 48).

Although the pollination biology of most species of Erythronium is not well known, that of the bumblebee-pollinated E. grandiflorum has been the subject of extensive study (e.g., J. D. Thomson and D. A. Stratton 1985; J. D. Thomson and B. A. Thomson 1989). The oligolectic bee Andrena erythronii is associated with Erythronium in northeastern North America, although A. erythronii visits other species of plants, and other insects also visit Erythronium (P. Bernhardt 1977; W. E. LaBerge 1987).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)
Key
1. Plants of e North America, from the Great Plains eastward.
→ 2
1. Plants of w North America, from the Rocky Mountains westward.
→ 7
2. Tepals yellow.
→ 3
2. Tepals white to pink or lavender.
→ 5
3. Capsule apex long-beaked; style persistent, forming beak on capsule; inner tepals with conspicuous, well-developed auricles.
E. rostratum
3. Capsule apex rounded, truncate, apiculate, umbilicate, or indented; style deciduous or base forming a small apiculum; auricles of inner tepals small or absent.
→ 4
4. Capsule apex rounded, truncate, or apiculate, capsules held erect or at least off ground; style swollen distally or ± terete; stigma lobes erect or recurved; inner tepals with small auricles; stolons 1–3 per bulb, mostly on 1-leaved plants.
E. americanum
4. Capsule apex indented, umbilicate, or rarely rounded, capsules ± resting on ground on reclining peduncles; style ± terete; stigma lobes spreading; tepals without auricles; stolons absent, or 1 per bulb of 1-leaved plants.
E. umbilicatum
5. Flowering plants reproducing vegetatively by stolons produced halfway up stem; tepals 8–15 mm; se Minnesota.
E. propullans
5. Flowering plants reproducing vegetatively by droppers or offshoots or by stolons arising from bulbs; tepals 15–40 mm; widespread.
→ 6
6. Tepals strongly reflexed at anthesis; leaf blade mottled, ± flat; capsules held erect; usually mesic bottomlands.
E. albidum
6. Tepals spreading at anthesis; leaf blade usually not mottled, conduplicate; capsules resting on ground; prairies, glades, dry, open woods.
E. mesochoreum
7. Leaf blade distinctly irregularly mottled with irregular streaks of brown or white; tepals violet-pink to white or creamy white, often yellow at base but never throughout.
→ 8
7. Leaf blade uniformly green (faintly mottled with brown or white in E. elegans and E. quinaultense); tepals yellow or white, sometimes pinkish in age.
→ 14
8. Filaments flattened, wider than 2 mm; stigma lobes 2–6 mm.
→ 9
8. Filaments linear, less than 0.8 mm wide; stigma unlobed or with lobes shorter than 4 mm.
→ 10
9. Tepals white to creamy white at anthesis, sometimes pinkish in age.
E. oregonum
9. Tepals uniformly clear violet-pink at anthesis.
E. revolutum
10. Tepals violet to pink, dark purple at base.
E. hendersonii
10. Tepals ± white with yellow base.
→ 11
11. Style 5–10 mm; anthers yellow, white, or cream (sometimes pink, reddish, or brownish red in forms of E. citrinum).
→ 12
11. Style 10–15 mm; anthers white to cream.
→ 13
12. Anthers yellow; style often bent; tepals bright yellow at base.
E. helenae
12. Anthers white to cream; style straight; tepals usually pale yellow at base.
E. citrinum
13. Scape (when flowers more than 1) branched well above leaves; bulbels sessile or absent; flowering individuals generally abundant in populations.
E. californicum
13. Scape (when flowers more than 1) branched near ground level; bulbels produced at ends of long slender stolons; flowering individuals generally uncommon in populations (most plants 1-leaved and vegetative).
E. multiscapideum
14. Tepals yellow.
→ 15
14. Tepals white to creamy white with yellow zone at base, sometimes tinged pink.
→ 17
15. Style and filaments yellow; tepals 15–28 mm; stigma unlobed or with very short, rounded lobes shorter than 1 mm; inflorescences 1–10-flowered.
E. pluriflorum
15. Style and filaments ± white; tepals 20–35 mm; stigma unlobed or with slender, recurved lobes (1–)2–4 mm; inflorescences 1–4-flowered.
→ 16
16. Inflorescences usually 1-flowered; style 10–15 mm; stigma unlobed or with lobes (1–)2–4 mm; tepals (in live specimens) often with narrow, paler zone at base.
E. grandiflorum
16. Inflorescences usually 1–4-flowered; style 8–10 mm; stigma unlobed or with lobes shorter than 1 mm; tepals uniformly yellow
E. tuolumnense
17. Stigma ± unlobed, or with lobes shorter than 1 mm.
→ 18
17. Stigma with slender, usually recurved lobes 1–5 mm.
→ 21
18. Tepals 10–20 mm, auricles absent.
E. purpurascens
18. Tepals 20–45 mm, inner auriculate.
→ 19
19. Tepals less than 1/3 yellow; filaments white; leaves 6–17 cm; inflorescences 1–3-flowered; sw Oregon, nw California
E. klamathense
19. Tepals 1/2–2/3 bright yellow proximally; filaments white or yellow; leaves 10–35 cm; inflorescences 1–8-flowered; Sierra Nevada of California.
→ 20
20. Filaments white; anthers yellow.
E. pusaterii
20. Filaments yellow; anthers cream.
E. taylorii
21. Tepals white to creamy white; filaments linear, less than 0.8 mm wide.
→ 22
21. Tepals tinged with pink; filaments linear to lanceolate, at least 0.8 mm wide.
→ 23
22. Tepals narrowly ovate, 20–35 mm, length at least 4 times width; style 15 mm or shorter; leaf blade narrowed gradually to petiole; nw Idaho, w Montana, e Washington.
E. grandiflorum
22. Tepals broadly ovate to broadly lanceolate, 25–45 mm, length (at least of the inner) less than 4 times width; style 13–25 mm; leaf blade narrowed ± abruptly to petiole; sw British Columbia, w Oregon, w Washington.
E. montanum
23. Inner tepals ± white, outer ± white and often strongly marked with pink, especially abaxially and along midline; Coast Ranges, Oregon.
E. elegans
23. All tepals white proximally, shading to pink at outer margins and tips; Olympic Mountains, Washington
E. quinaultense
Source FNA vol. 26, p. 160. FNA vol. 26, p. 153. Authors: Geraldine A. Allen, Kenneth R. Robertson.
Parent taxa Liliaceae > Erythronium Liliaceae
Sibling taxa
E. albidum, E. americanum, E. californicum, E. elegans, E. grandiflorum, E. helenae, E. hendersonii, E. klamathense, E. mesochoreum, E. montanum, E. multiscapideum, E. oregonum, E. pluriflorum, E. propullans, E. purpurascens, E. pusaterii, E. quinaultense, E. revolutum, E. rostratum, E. taylorii, E. tuolumnense, E. umbilicatum
Subordinate taxa
E. albidum, E. americanum, E. californicum, E. citrinum, E. elegans, E. grandiflorum, E. helenae, E. hendersonii, E. klamathense, E. mesochoreum, E. montanum, E. multiscapideum, E. oregonum, E. pluriflorum, E. propullans, E. purpurascens, E. pusaterii, E. quinaultense, E. revolutum, E. rostratum, E. taylorii, E. tuolumnense, E. umbilicatum
Synonyms E. citrinum var. roderickii, E. howellii
Name authority S. Watson: Proc. Amer. Acad. Arts 22: 480. (1887) Linnaeus: Sp. Pl. 1: 305. (1753): Gen. Pl. ed. 5, 145. (1754)
Web links 
Unless otherwise noted, all data comes from the online version of the Flora of North America, who have made most of their content available via a Creative Commons license (CC BY 4.0).



Type/paste one or more Latin names into the boxes above; matching taxa will show up below the box as you type. You can use the up/down arrow keys to move through the list.

(If the plant you're looking for doesn't show up in the auto-complete list, that means it either isn't described in Flora of North America yet, or it's listed under a synonym. And please note that Flora of North America is still missing several plant families, including Fabaceae, Apiaceae, Boraginaceae, and Polemoniaceae.)

Choose a data source: Flora of North America, OregonFlora, UW Burke Herbarium

The species comparison tool is brought to you by:
Northwest Wildflowers