Flora of North America species comparison

The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Eleocharis

Eleocharis subg. Limnochloa

spike-rush, spikesedge, éléocharide
Habit Herbs, annual or perennial, usually cespitose, often rhizomatous, sometimes stoloniferous; rhizomes rarely with terminal tubers or bulbs, horizontal and long or ascending and caudexlike. Plants perennial, when submerged sometimes with spikelets proliferating.
Rhizomes

present, creeping, sometimes with apical tubers.
Culms

sometimes solitary, terete, 3–5-angled or more, or strongly compressed in cross section, spongy with internal air cavities and incomplete transverse septa or sometimes hollow with complete transverse septa.

16–115 cm × 0.5–8.5 mm, spongy with transverse septa incomplete or often hollow with complete transverse septa.
Leaves

basal, 2 per culm;

ligules absent;

blades absent or a mucro or awn (tooth) at apex of sheath, very rarely flattened, to 6 cm.

Inflorescences

terminal;

spikelet 1;

involucral bracts absent, rarely a proximal scale of spikelet resembling short bract.

Spikelets

scales 4–500 or more, spirally or rarely distichously arranged, each subtending flower or proximal 1–2(–3) empty, stramineous (straw-brown) to medium brown or red brown or blackish brown.

cylindric to narrowly ellipsoid, terete, often as wide as their culms, (6–)9–75 mm;

rachilla with proximal internodes about the same thickness and length as internodes in middle of spikelet;

proximal scale empty or rarely subtending a flower;

floral scales ca. 4–220 per spikelet, spiraled, 3–8 mm, with 15 or more prominent to obscure, close, longitudinal veins, papery to cartilaginous.
Flowers

bisexual;

perianth of (0–)3–6(–10) bristles, straight or curved, shorter than to 2 times longer than achene, retrorsely (to antrorsely) spinulose or sometimes smooth;

stamens 1–3;

styles linear, 2–3-fid, base (tubercle) usually persistent, usually enlarged, usually different in appearance from achene.

Styles

3-fid, or 3-fid and 2-fid.
Achenes

biconvex, plano-convex, or trigonous to subterete.

biconvex, sometimes compressed trigonous, sometimes distally constricted into a distinct, thick neck, 1.4–3 mm, markedly (to obscurely) sculptured, each face usually with 10–40 longitudinal rows of enlarged cells, sometimes nearly smooth.
Tubercles

distinct from achenes in color, texture and form, or sometimes merging with achene apex, often dorsoventrally greatly compressed.

Eleocharis

Eleocharis subg. Limnochloa
Distribution
from USDA
Worldwide
[BONAP county map]
Tropical; subtropical (and warm temperate) areas worldwide
Discussion

Species ca. 200 (67 in the flora).

The name of the genus has sometimes been given as Heleocharis Lestibudois; this is now regarded as an orthographic variant of Eleocharis.

Eleocharis dulcis (Burman f.) Trinius ex Henschel is sometimes cultivated for its edible tubers. Some species are weeds in rice fields, mostly extraterritorially. Almost all species are restricted to wetlands, often emergent, and sometimes submerged aquatic.

No recent comprehensive worldwide taxonomic treatment of Eleocharis is available. The treatment herein is based mostly on the extensive studies by H. K. Svenson (1929, 1932, 1934, 1937, 1939, 1947, 1957), which were mostly restricted to species of North America. Classification of Eleocharis is unusually difficult because relatively few macroscopic characters are provided by the simple structure characteristic of the genus (only two leaves, basal, without blades or with only rudimentary blades, and unbranched aerial stems, each with a single terminal spikelet and without an involucral bract). Undoubtedly much evolutionary convergence has occurred in most vegetative and reproductive structures (M. S. González-E. and J. A. Tena-F. 2000; E. H. Roalson and E. A. Friar 2000).

North American Eleocharis includes some extremely difficult species complexes that need taxonomic revision: (1) The E. palustris complex (species 1–7) is discussed under 1. E. palustris. (2) The E. tenuis complex (species 16–21) is discussed under 21. E. tenuis. (3) The four species (species 57–60) of 8c. Eleocharis subg. Zinserlingia that occur in North America belong to the E. quinqueflora (= E. pauciflora) complex, discussed under subg. Zinserlingia. (4) All six species of 8a2b. E. ser. Ovatae (species 42–47) constitute a complex discussed under ser. Ovatae.

The supraspecific classification of Eleocharis used here is that of M. S. González-E. and P. M. Peterson (1997), which was based on a study of most species worldwide. Other recent classifications are based on more or less regional studies (H. K. Svenson 1957; T. V. Egorova 1981; I. Kukkonen 1990). A study using limited DNA data from 30 species (E. H. Roalson and E. A. Friar 2000), mostly from North America, indicates that the following supraspecific taxa are probably monophyletic: 8a2a. ser. Maculosae, 8a2b. ser. Ovatae, and 8d. subg. Limnochloa, whereas the following taxa are probably para- or polyphyletic: 8a1. sect. Eleocharis, 8a1a. ser. Eleocharis, 8a1d. ser. Tenuissimae, and 8a2. sect. Eleogenus.

Users of this treatment should be aware of the following: culms that are smooth when fresh are often ridged when dry; culms of pressed specimens are often flattened and must be carefully rehydrated and sectioned to determine the original cross-section shape; culm widths given here are usually for culms pressed flat; floral scale widths are measured on flattened scales or by doubling the width measured on scales folded along the midrib; and achene length does not include the tubercle, which is often included in descriptions published elsewhere. In this treatment, I describe the tubercle (style base) after the achene in consecutive sentences to stress the separate nature of the two structures.

Some species, mostly of 8a1d. Eleocharis ser. Tenuissimae, often proliferate from spikelets, often on arching or horizontal culms, especially when growing as submerged or floating aquatics. Because many such plants reproduce entirely asexually and have no normal spikelets or achenes, it is often impossible to identify them to species. The invalid name E. prolifera Torrey has sometimes been used for these plants. Species of ser. Tenuissimae in which the spikelets may be proliferous and which are easily confused with each other are E. baldwinii, E. brittonii, E. microcarpa, E. nana, E. retroflexa, and E. vivipara. Aquatic forms of at least some of those species are very hard to distinguish from Websteria confervoides (Poiret) S. S. Hooper. Other species in which the spikelets often poliferate or the culm tips root are E. pachycarpa of ser. Tenuissimae, E. melanocarpa of 8a1b. ser. Melanocarpae, and E. rostellata of 8a1c. ser. Rostellatae. When submersed, plants of E. acicularis of 8b. subg. Scirpidium and E. elongata and E. robbinsii of 8d. subg. Limnochloa may be entirely vegetative, the latter two species sometimes forming whorls of flaccid stems without spikelets.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species ca. 21 (7 in the flora).

Eleocharis dulcis (Burman f.) Trinius, the Chinese water-chestnut, is sometimes cultivated in the southeastern United States for the edible tubers produced by some cultivars. According to D. B. Ward and E. M. Leigh (1976), it is also occasionally grown as an aquarium or fish-pond novelty; it apparently does not persist or escape. Because E. dulcis is a widely distributed aquatic weed in Asia, it might escape from cultivation in North America as well. It is most similar to E. interstincta and E. equisetoides; it has completely smooth achenes. Eleocharis fistulosa (Poiret) Link (= E. acutangula (Roxburgh) Schultes) was cited from North America by H. K. Svenson (1957) and D. S. Correll and H. B. Correll (1972) on the basis of Runyon’s specimens from Texas, which belong to E. obtusetrigona (Lindley & Nees) Steudel.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)
Key

Key to the subgenera of Eleocharis

1. Spikelet scales with 15+ prominent to obscure, close, longitudinal veins running length of scale; achenes markedly (to obscurely) sculptured at 10–15X, with 10–40 longitudinal rows of enlarged, horizontally elongated or isodiametric cells that are not distinctly depressed; spikelets cylindric to narrowly ellipsoid, (6–)9–76 mm, often as wide as culms; culms often hollow with complete transverse septa.
subg. Limnochloa
1. Spikelet scales with 1 vein (midrib) or rarely to 10 widely spaced longitudinal veins; achenes smooth to markedly sculptured at 10X, if with longitudinal rows of enlarged cells at 10X then cells distinctly depressed; spikelets mostly ovoid, seldom cylindric or narrowly ellipsoid, rarely as wide as culms; culms rarely hollow with complete transverse septa.
→ 2
2. Achenes with 9–13 longitudinal rows of fine horizontal ridges (trabeculae) between much more prominent longitudinal ridges and achene angles, trigonous or nearly circular in cross section; spikelets with proximal scale subtending flower; distal leaf sheaths thinly membranous-hyaline, often disintegrating; culms to 1.5 mm wide, spongy.
subg. Scirpidium
2. Achenes without longitudinal rows of fine horizontal ridges, biconvex to trigonous or nearly circular in cross section; spikelets with proximal scale subtending flower or not (empty); distal leaf sheaths papery to thinly membranous-hyaline, persistent or disintegrating; culms to 5 mm wide.
→ 3
3. Proximal internodes of rachillae thicker and shorter than internodes in middle of spikelet; spikelet scales 4–12 per spikelet; rhizomes present, often with terminal bulb; achenes usually distally narrowed into thick beaklike region, smooth or finely longitudinally ridged or reticulate at 10–20X, 1.5–2.7 mm; tubercles often similar to and merging with achene apex in color, texture, and form.
subg. Zinserlingia
3. Proximal internodes of rachillae as thick and long as internodes in middle of spikelet; spikelet scales 5–500+ per spikelet; rhizomes present or absent, without bulb, sometimes (in 8a3. sect. Parvulae) with terminal tuber; achenes rarely distally narrowed into thick beaklike region, never finely longitudinally ridged, smooth or variously sculptured at 10–20X, 0.4–2 mm; tubercles clearly different from achene apex in color, texture, and form and not merging with achene apex, or rarely similar to and merging with achene apex (in 8a1c. ser. Rostellatae and 8a3. sect. Parvulae).
subg. Eleocharis

Key to the species of Eleocharis subg. Limnochloa

1. Spikelets 1.4–3 mm wide, with 4–26 floral scales; submersed plants often forming flaccid culms without spikelets.
→ 2
1. Spikelets 3–8 mm wide, with 30–220 floral scales; plants never forming flaccid culms without spikelets.
→ 3
2. Achenes 0.65–1.3 × 0.5–0.8 mm; floral scales with (rarely without) conspicuous brown to blackish submarginal band.
E. elongata
2. Achenes 1.9–2.6 × 1–1.4 mm; floral scales without (rarely with) conspicuous submarginal band.
E. robbinsii
3. Culms hollow, with complete transverse septa (mostly evident externally).
→ 4
3. Culms internally spongy, with incomplete transverse septa.
→ 5
4. Achenes markedly sculptured, the longitudinal rows of enlarged cells clearly rectangular, separated by distinct longitudinal lines; perianth bristles broad and stout, exceeding achene; culms smooth or sometimes septate-nodulose proximally.
E. interstincta
4. Achenes obscurely sculptured, sometimes partially smooth, the longitudinal rows of enlarged cells linear, separated by obscure longitudinal lines; perianth bristles narrow and weak, rudimentary to equaling achene; culms septate-nodulose through out.
E. equisetoides
5. Culms clearly acutely 4 angled.
E. quadrangulata
5. Culms terete or obscurely 3–5-angled.
→ 6
6. Floral scales broadly suborbicular; tubercles 0.1–0.5 × 0.2–0.5 mm, confluent with or narrower than achene apex; achene apex narrowed into stout spongy region; perianth bristles smooth or rarely finely spinulose.
E. cellulosa
6. Floral scales ovate to oblong; tubercles 0.8–1.1 × 0.7–0.9 mm, proximally wider than achene apex; achene apex without stout spongy region; perianth bristles coarsely spinulose.
E. obtusetrigona
Source FNA vol. 23, p. 60. Treatment authors: S. Galen Smith*, Jeremy J. Bruhl*, M. Socorro González-Elizondo*, Francis J. Menapace*. FNA vol. 23. Treatment author: M. Socorro González-Elizondo.
Parent taxa Cyperaceae Cyperaceae > Eleocharis
Subordinate taxa
E. subg. Eleocharis, E. subg. Limnochloa, E. subg. Scirpidium, E. subg. Zinserlingia
E. cellulosa, E. elongata, E. equisetoides, E. interstincta, E. obtusetrigona, E. quadrangulata, E. robbinsii
Synonyms Scirpus unranked E. subg. Limnochloa, E. series Mutatae
Name authority R. Brown: Prodr., 224. (1810) (Palisot de Beauvois ex T. Lestiboudois) Torrey: Ann. Lyceum Nat. Hist. New York 3: 296. (1836)
Web links 
Unless otherwise noted, all data comes from the online version of the Flora of North America, who have made most of their content available via a Creative Commons license (CC BY 4.0).



Type/paste one or more Latin names into the boxes above; matching taxa will show up below the box as you type. You can use the up/down arrow keys to move through the list.

(If the plant you're looking for doesn't show up in the auto-complete list, that means it either isn't described in Flora of North America yet, or it's listed under a synonym. And please note that Flora of North America is still missing several plant families, including Apiaceae, Boraginaceae, and Polemoniaceae.)

The species comparison tool is brought to you by:
Northwest Wildflowers