1. Stem length 8-50 times diam.; roots (one or all of them) tuberlike, several times thicker than stems. | E. poselgeri |
1. Stem length 1-8 times diam.; roots diffuse, not tuberlike or enlarged | → 2 |
2. Stem length usually 3-8 times diam., semiprostrate or decumbent; s Texas | → 3 |
2. Stems compact, length 1-3 times diam., erect or ascending; mostly widespread | → 6 |
3. Tepals yellow with orange-red or purple proximal regions | E. papillosus |
3. Tepals pink to purple with white, yellow, green, or purple proximal regions | → 4 |
4. Tepals white or yellow in proximal regions; stem ribs 4-5; areoles of flower and fruit bearing soft hairs to 3-6 mm in addition to spines | E. pentalophus |
4. Tepals green or purple in proximal regions; stem ribs (5-)7-9(-10); areoles of flower and fruit bearing short wool about 1.5 mm in addition to spines | → 5 |
5. Radial spines to 10 mm; crests of ribs conspicuously undulate or almost completely interrupted between the areoles; stems 1.5-3 cm diam. | E. berlandieri |
5. Radial spines 9.5-33+ mm; crests of ribs nearly straight on healthy, distal parts of plant (prior to stem shrinkage); stems 3.2-7.5+ cm diam. | E. enneacanthus |
6. Flowers displaying hummingbird pollination syndrome, having at least one of the following features: inner tepals both crimson/scarlet/carmine and more than 15 mm; tips stiff, strong enough for hummingbirds to perch on, rounded or slightly hooded; anthers pink to (yellowish) purple; inner stamens longer than outer stamens; innermost stamens connate basally forming a tubular extension of the nectar chamber; flowers remaining fully open at night and in cold temperatures | → 7 |
6. Flowers displaying bee pollination syndrome, having inner tepals yellow to brownish or pink to purple, 10-69(-77) mm (carmine and 20-35 mm or less in some populations of E. viridiflorus); inner tepal tips usually somewhat pointed and/or thin and delicate; anthers yellowish; inner stamens shorter than outer, never proximally connate into a tubular extension of the nectar chamber; flowers partly or completely closing at night and in cold temperatures | → 9 |
7. Largest spines usually terete (rarely somewhat flat); inner tepals usually crimson or scarlet; plants dioecious or not, polyploid | E. coccineus |
7. Largest spines angular or terete in cross section; inner tepals usually carmine or crimson; plants not dioecious, diploid | → 8 |
8. Spines 3-11 per areole, angled and/or papillate (use lens 15×); ribs 5-8; central spines 0-1(-4) per areole; California eastward to Colorado, northern | E. triglochidiatus |
8. Spines [8-]9-18 per areole, angled to terete; ribs 8-13; central spines 1-8 per areole; Arizona and New Mexico, southern | E. arizonicus |
9. Inner tepals usually 15 mm or less, greenish or brownish (rarely carmine) | → 10 |
9. Inner tepals 20 mm or more, showy, pink to purple or yellow, at least in distal 1/2 | → 11 |
10. Plants remaining tiny, (1-)2-3 × 1-2(-2.5) cm; ribs 6-9; spines 8-14(-15) per areole; endemic near Marathon, Texas | E. davisii |
10. Plants larger at maturity, (3-)8-30(-35) × 2.8-9 cm; ribs 10-20; spines (13-)18-30(-55) per areole; widespread (if near Marathon, Texas, then not flowering until much larger than E. davisii) | E. viridiflorus |
11. Central spines shorter than the longest radial spines, or absent, 2-17(-30) mm; stems usually spheric to short cylindric; plants usually 0-10-branched; interareolar distance short, 3-15 mm; spines ± obscuring stem surface | → 12 |
11. Central spines mostly longer than longest radial spines, usually 20-80 mm; stems elongate, usually short to long cylindric; plants usually branched with age (except in E. fendleri), branches (4-)12-500; interareolar distance relatively long, (12-)15-52 mm; spines obscuring stem surface or often not | → 18 |
12. Flower tube hairs usually less than 3 mm; spines of flower tube thick, more spinelike than bristlelike; young flower buds appearing relatively naked or merely spiny, never completely hidden by vestiture; flowers succulent and durable, re-opening for 2 to several days; flower tube walls thick distally | → 13 |
12. Flower tube hairs 3-15 mm (2 mm in E. rigidissimus); spines of flower tube unusually slender, relatively bristlelike; young flower buds hidden by their own long wool and bristles; flowers ephemeral, often wilting after only a few hours; flower tube walls thin | → 15 |
13. Radial spines (9-)11-16 per areole; central spines (0-)1-43 per areole; inner tepals deep magenta or purple, proximally green to very dark purple; Arizona | E. bonkerae |
13. Radial spines 13-28 per areole; central spines 1-15 per areole; inner tepals yellow, pink, or purple, proximally white and green or only green; Texas, New Mexico | → 14 |
14. Inner tepals pink or magenta, white banded in proximal 1/2; plants diploid | E. pectinatus |
14. Inner tepals pink, purple, yellow, or other colors, green proximally; plants tetraploid | E. dasyacanthus |
15. Plants from far west of the Rio Grande, mostly west of the Continental Divide | → 16 |
15. Plants from east of the Rio Grande | → 17 |
16. Central spines (0-)1-4 in all or most areoles, sometimes extremely short and inconspicuous; inner tepals darker proximally, not white banded | E. pseudopectinatus |
16. Central spines always absent; inner tepals white banded prox- imally | E. rigidissimus |
17. Radial spines 10-17; central spines (1-)2(-6) per areole, 3.5-7 mm; rare, Big Bend National Park, Texas. | E. chisosensis |
17. Radial spines 12-36; central spines 0-7 per areole, usually 1-6 mm; relatively widespread, but not in Big Bend National Park, Texas | E. reichenbachii |
18. Floral tissue darkening in fluid preservative (except in E. fendleri); Chihuahuan Desert and eastward | → 19 |
18. Floral tissue whitening in fluid preservative; west of Chihuahuan Desert (west of the Continental Divide, except for E. fendleri) | → 22 |
19. Receptacle walls greatly thickened distally; bases of inner tepals broad, thick, and widely separated | E. fendleri |
19. Receptacle walls thinner distally; bases of inner tepals not thick, not widely separated | → 20 |
20. Stems slender 3.2-4.5(-7.5) cm diam.; plants ultimately forming lax clumps, general aspect green (not hidden by spines); east of Chihuahuan Desert | E. enneacanthus |
20. Stems robust 4.5-14(-15) cm diam.; plants lax clumps or dense hemispheric mounds, general aspect either green or spine-covered; Chihuahuan Desert | → 21 |
21. Surfaces of largest spines often splitting longitudinally when weathered; fruits 20-30 mm; spines white, gray, or brown, seldom hiding green aspect of stems; clumps mostly open, relatively lax or sprawling (rarely prostrate); areoles 19-52 mm apart along ribs; diploid | E. enneacanthus |
21. Surfaces of largest spines not splitting or fraying; fruits 35-40(-50); spines translucent straw yellow, only darkest spines sometimes tan or brown, partly hiding stem surface, imparting a generally yellow aspect; clumps dense, hemispheric mounds (unless etiolated in deep shade); areoles 12-20(-25) mm apart along ribs; tetraploid | E. stramineus |
22. Plants at least 15 cm; spines yellow; stem surface yellow-green; fruits green, sometimes tinged reddish to brownish, pulp white | → 23 |
22. Plants usually at least 7.5 cm, sometimes as short as 5 cm; spines usually white, gray, brown, or black, occasionally yellow; stem surface green, though somewhat hidden by spines; fruits maroon, red, or rose-pink, pulp white, pink, or magenta | → 24 |
23. Central spines 4-6(-8) per areole, 30-72 mm; abaxial central spine usually straight, flat or angled, white; inner tepals usually pale pink (to magenta), proximally greenish; desert scrub of Arizona and Mexico | E. nicholii |
23. Central spines 1(-5) per areole, 20-25 mm; abaxial central spine strongly down-curved in proximal 1/3, terete, colored like other spines in same areole; inner tepals magenta to rose-purple, proximally darker; interior chaparral and oak scrub of Arizona | E. ledingii |
24. Stems relatively tuberculate, ovoid to short cylindric; spines 4-8 per areole; abaxial radial spine flat; sole central spine terete; habitat above 1400 m | E. fendleri |
24. Stems obviously ribbed, short cylindric or commonly 2-4 times longer than thick; spines 9-20 per areole; all radial spines terete, not flat; abaxial central spine often flat; habitat mostly below 1400 m | → 25 |
25. Abaxial central spine flat, sharp-angled in cross section, usually white; central spines 4 or more per areole | E. engelmannii |
25. Abaxial (or solitary) central spine terete (intermediates key both ways), colored like other central spines; central spines 1-4 per areole | → 26 |
26. Central spines (0-)1(-3) per areole | E. fendleri |
26. Central spines (1-)2-4 per areole | → 27 |
27. Ribs relatively numerous, 12-18(-20); diploid; Yavapai, Maricopa, Pinal, Gila, and possibly Graham counties, central Arizona | E. bonkerae |
27. Ribs relatively few, 10-15; tetraploid; widespread in Arizona | → 28 |
28. Plants relatively short, compact; spines 8-16 per areole; areoles 10-15 mm apart; above 600 m, c and s Arizona, including upper Verde Valley | E. fasciculatus |
28. Plants relatively tall; spines (8-)15-20 per areole; areoles 6-10(-15) mm apart; below 600 m or, if relatively small and/or from higher altitudes, then from n or w Arizona | E. engelmannii |