FNA: Dryopteridaceae vs. Diplazium

Distribution

Worldwide

Discussion

The family Dryopteridaceae has been variously circumscribed; it is here delimited in a manner similar to that of R. M. Tryon and A. F. Tryon (1982) but with the inclusion of Nephrolepis. In many works, the family has gone under the illegitimate name Aspidiaceae. Some authorities define Dryopteridaceae more narrowly, to exclude Athyrium, Deparia, Diplazium, Cystopteris, and Gymnocarpium (Athyriaceae or Woodsiaceae), Woodsia (Woodsiaceae), Lomariopsis (Lomariopsidaceae), Nephrolepis (Nephrolepidaceae or Davalliaceae), Onoclea and Matteuccia (Onocleaceae), and Ctenitis and Tectaria (Tectariaceae). Characteristics holding Dryopteridaceae (as circumscribed here) together include the bilateral, monolete spores, often broadly winged perispore, absence of needlelike hairs, scaly stem and petiole bases, abaxial (nonmarginal) sori, base chromosome number of 40 or 41 (also 38 and 39 in Woodsia, 37 in Onoclea, 42 in Cystopteris), and usually indusiate sori. Loss of indusium, dimorphism, areolate venation, and reduced blade dissection have occurred repeatedly along many evolutionary lines in Dryopteridaceae, and in general these characteristics are often not very useful in delimiting genera or assessing intergeneric relationships.

In some genera, especially Phanerophlebia and Polystichum, the blade bears very narrow scales (sometimes called microscales) that resemble uniseriate hairs. These scales may be only one or two cells wide. Every intergradation exists between these filiform microscales and more typical, wider scales, and the two types are the same color, generally tan to brownish. Microscales are probably not homologous with true hairs, which may be either unicellular or multicellular, uncolored or sometimes reddish (as in Tectaria and Ctenitis), glandular (as in Woodsia) or not. Hairs in Dryopteridaceae, if present at all, are generally readily distinguishable from the needlelike, transparent ones found in Thelypteridaceae.

Genera ca. 60, species perhaps exceeding 3000 (18 genera, 79 species in the flora).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

In a few species outside the flora, rachises and costae bear multicellular hairs like those of Deparia, which differs from Diplazium in having grooves of costae not decurrent onto rachis groove, veins free or anastomosing, sori long or short and costular, and indusia present or absent. Many species of Diplazium are known to reproduce apogamously.

Species about 400 (3 in the flora).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key

1. Leaves strongly dimorphic, either fertile or sterile, the 2 types very dissimilar.	→ 2
1. Leaves monomorphic, fertile and sterile similar in size and dissection, occasionally with somewhat contracted fertile pinnae on same leaf as sterile pinnae (as in Polystichum acrostichoides).	→ 5
2. Sporangia completely covering abaxial surface of blade, not in discrete sori or hidden by revolute segment margins; sterile blades 1-pinnate, pinnae serrate.	Lomariopsis
2. Sporangia not covering abaxial surface of blade, in discrete sori or hidden by revolute segment margins; sterile blades variously divided, not 1-pinnate with pinnae serrate.	→ 3
3. Plants hemiepiphytic, rooted in ground and with stems climbing trees; sterile blades 3-4-pinnate; indusia thick, conspicuous.	Maxonia
3. Plants terrestrial, not climbing; sterile blades deeply pinnatifid to 1-pinnate-pinnatifid; indusia thin, fragile, hidden by revolute segment margins.	→ 4
4. Sterile blades pinnatifid to 1-pinnate at base; venation areolate; fertile blades 2-pinnate, sori enclosed in small, globose, hardened pinnules.	Onoclea
4. Sterile blades 1-pinnate-pinnatifid; veins free; fertile blades 1-pinnate, sori on linear pinnae and enclosed by hardened pinna margin.	Matteuccia
5. Stolons present, wiry, arising from stem; blades 1-pinnate; pinnae articulate to rachis, sometimes deciduous with age; indusia lunate to reniform or circular with narrow sinus.	Nephrolepis
5. Stolons absent; blades variously divided; pinnae not articulate to rachis, or rarely proximal pinnae weakly articulate but not deciduous; indusia various or absent.	→ 6
6. Indusia completely surrounding receptacle and composed of filaments or scalelike segments arranged in cuplike fashion around sorus; petiole base with 2 vascular bundles; scales absent on costae abaxially.	Woodsia
6. Indusia attached centrally or laterally, not completely surrounding receptacle, or indusia absent; petiole base with 2 or more vascular bundles; scales absent or present on costae abaxially.	→ 7
7. Veins areolate or copiously anastomosing.	→ 8
7. Veins free or only casually and sparingly anastomosing.	→ 10
8. Sori and indusia linear; petiole base with 2 vascular bundles.	Diplazium
8. Sori round, with indusia round or round-reniform; petiole base with many vascular bundles.	→ 9
9. Costae adaxially rounded or flattened, bearing multicellular reddish hairs; margins of pinnae lacking spinules or teeth.	Tectaria
9. Costae adaxially grooved, lacking reddish multicellular hairs but sometimes with tan, very reduced, filiform scales; margins of pinnae spinulose to denticulate or crenate.	Cyrtomium
10. Indusia round, attached at center (peltate); sori round; petiole base with 3 or more vascular bundles.	→ 11
10. Indusia round-reniform, reniform, linear, or absent, attached laterally at sinus; sori round or elongate; petiole base with 2 or more vascular bundles.	→ 12
11. Blades 1-pinnate with terminal pinna similar to lateral pinnae; sori in 2-4 rows between costa and margin; s Arizona to w Texas.	Phanerophlebia
11. Blades 1-3-pinnate with gradually reduced and pinnatifid apex; sori in 1(-2) rows between costa and margin or between costule and margin; widespread.	Polystichum
12. Sori elongate, straight or hooked at one end, indusiate; petiole base with 2 vascular bundles.	→ 13
12. Sori round or nearly so, indusia present or absent; petiole with 2 or more vascular bundles.	→ 15
13. Adaxial grooves of costae shallow, not decurrent into rachis groove; multicellular hairs borne along costae, especially adaxially; stems moderately long-creeping; blades 1-pinnate-pinnatifid.	Deparia
13. Adaxial grooves of costae deep, decurrent into rachis groove; multicellular hairs absent on costae; stems short-creeping to erect; blades 1-pinnate to 2-pinnate-pinnatifid.	→ 14
14. Blades commonly 2-pinnate or more divided; proximal pinnae often slightly to greatly reduced; sori usually hooked at distal end.	Athyrium
14. Blades 1-pinnate, 1-pinnate-pinnatifid, or 2-pinnate (if 2-pinnate then veins anastomosing); proximal pinnae not or slightly reduced; sori ± straight, not hooked at distal end.	Diplazium
15. Costae rounded or flat adaxially, bearing dense, obviously multicellular hairs with reddish crosswalls.	Ctenitis
15. Costae grooved adaxially, lacking hairs.	→ 16
16. Indusia attached at distinct sinus, round-reniform; petiole base with 3 or more vascular bundles.	→ 17
16. Indusia absent or laterally attached and hoodlike, arching over sori; petiole base with 2 vascular bundles.	→ 18
17. Stems short-creeping, nearly erect or erect; blades lanceolate to ovate, not pentagonal; widespread.	Dryopteris
17. Stems moderately long-creeping; blades pentagonal, with basal basiscopic pinnules decidedly longer than next pair; South Carolina.	Arachniodes
18. Stems long-creeping; blades deltate to pentagonal, proximal pinnae by far the largest; petioles mostly 1/3-3 times length of blades.	→ 19
18. Stems short-creeping to ascending; blades ovate to lanceolate, proximal pinnae occasionally slightly longer than adjacent pair; petioles mostly shorter than blades.	→ 20
19. Indusia present but often inconspicuous in mature leaves, laterally attached and arching over sori; segment margins serrate-dentate (Cystopteris montana).	Cystopteris
19. Indusia always absent; segment margins entire or crenate but never serrate-dentate.	Gymnocarpium
20. Indusia absent from all sori; stems erect to ascending, surface obscured by petiole bases and scales, scales more than 5 mm.	Athyrium
20. Indusia present but often inconspicuous in mature leaves, laterally attached and arching over sori; stems decumbent, usually creeping, surface often visible through petiole bases and scales, scales less than 5 mm.	Cystopteris

1. Leaves 2-pinnate; veins anastomosing.	D. esculentum
1. Leaves 1-pinnate or 1-pinnate-pinnatifid; veins free.	→ 2
2. Scales brown, entire; pinnae nearly entire.	D. pycnocarpon
2. Scales dark brown, dentate; pinnae lobed.	D. lonchophyllum