The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Whipple cholla

cane cholla, walking stick cholla, walkingstick cactus

Habit Trees or shrubs, low to upright, sparingly to densely branched, some almost matlike in Arizona, 0.3–0.6(–1.5) m; branchlets whorled to subwhorled. Trees, compact, widely branching, 0.4–2 m. Stem segments firmly attached, whorled or subwhorled, green to purple, 5–23 × 1.3–3.5 cm; tubercles crowded, pronounced, oval to narrowly oval, 0.5–1.2(–1.5) cm; areoles broadly obdeltate to elliptic, 4.5–7 × 2–4 mm; wool yellow to tan, aging gray to black.
Stem

segments firmly attached, green, 3–9(–15) × 0.5–1.5(–2.2) cm;

tubercles prominent, short, 0.5–1 cm;

areoles oval to obdeltate, 2–6 × 1.5–4 mm;

wool pale yellow to white, aging gray.

Spines

(1–)3–8(–10) spines per areole, in all but basalmost areoles, best developed toward apex, interlacing with spines of adjacent areoles, whitish or pale yellow, pale red-brown, sometimes tipped yellow, of 2 kinds;

radial spines slender, flattened basally, deflexed, 5–8 mm, surrounding central spines;

central spines usually 4(–6), spreading into a cross, stout, subterete, 2–3.4(–4.5) cm;

also 0–2 bristlelike spines;

sheaths whitish to pale yellow (rarely golden) throughout or tipped yellow to golden.

(4–)6–18(–24) per areole, at most areoles, interlacing with spines of adjacent areoles, pale tan (rarely yellowish), pinkish to red-brown;

abaxial spines erect to usually deflexed, terete, often flattened basally, 8–19 mm;

adaxial spines erect or spreading, subterete; ± bristlelike spines at areole abaxial margins;

sheaths persisting, uniformly whitish, not baggy.

Glochids

in adaxial tuft, yellow, 1–3 mm.

in inconspicuous adaxial tuft, yellow to tan, aging gray, 1–2 mm.

Flowers

inner tepals yellow to green-yellow, spatulate, 15–25(–30) mm, apiculate;

filaments yellowish or yellow-green;

anthers yellow;

style white to yellowish;

stigma lobes whitish, yellowish, or pale green (rarely pink tinged).

inner tepals rose to red-purple, bronze-purple, or yellow, sometimes pale greenish yellow or whitish, spatulate, 18–35 mm, emarginate-apiculate;

filaments deep purple to pink-purple, sometimes green;

anthers pale yellow;

style white or pink to purple distally;

stigma lobes white to cream.

Fruits

rarely proliferating, yellow to greenish yellow, broadly cylindric to subspheric, 18–30(–35) × 15–22(–32) mm, fleshy, tuberculate, spineless;

tubercles subequal or distalmost longest, usually prominent;

umbilicus 7–8 mm deep;

areoles 36–62.

rarely proliferating, yellow, sometimes tinged reddish to purplish, broadly cylindric, 20–50 × 17–30 mm, fleshy, strongly tuberculate, spineless;

areoles 28–50(–62);

tubercles longer in distal portion of fruit;

umbilicus to 10 mm deep.

Seeds

pale yellow, subcircular to slightly angular in outline, flattened to warped, 3–3.5 × 2.5–3.5 mm, sides smooth or with 1–3 depressions;

girdle smooth.

pale yellow, suborbicular to oval in outline, flattened to warped, 4–5 × 3–4 mm, sides with 0–3 large depressions;

girdle smooth.

2n

= 22, 44.

= 22.

Cylindropuntia whipplei

Cylindropuntia spinosior

Phenology Flowering late spring–early summer (May–Jul). Flowering spring–early summer (Apr–Aug).
Habitat Desert and plains grasslands, juniper woodlands, oak, pinyon, or pine forests, sagebrush Desert and plains grasslands, extending onto Sonoran Desert flats, sandy to loamy soils
Elevation 900-2300 m (3000-7500 ft) 300-2000 m (1000-6600 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
AZ; CO; NM; NV; UT
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
AZ; NM; Mexico (Chihuahua, Sonora)
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Cylindropuntia whipplei hybridizes with C. acanthocarpa in central Arizona; the hybrids [= C. ×congesta (Griffiths) F. M. Knuth (as species) (D. J. Pinkava 1999)] are compact shrubs with long-tuberculate stem segments 8–12 mm thick, bearing 0–4 erect or deflexed spines per areole, and tuberculate, green to yellowish fruits occasionally bearing one to few spines, and have chromosome number of 2n = 22. In areas of Arizona, Nevada, and Utah, C. whipplei hybridizes with C. echinocarpa, particularly with the low, compact form of C. echinocarpa; the hybrids [= C. ×multigeniculata (Clokey) Backeberg] have spineless to nearly spineless fruits, numerous intergrading spines per stem areole that are not dimorphic, and chromosome number of 2n = 22. Hybrids between C. whipplei and C. imbricata [= C. ×viridiflora (Britton & Rose) F. M. Knuth], which are found in scattered localities in northern New Mexico and northeastern Arizona, have a low, bushy habit, ripe cantaloupe-colored inner tepals, an irregular, monomorphic spine pattern, and a chromosome number of 2n = 22. Cylindropuntia ×media P. V. Heath, from the base of Wolf Creek Pass, Colorado (G. Arp 1973), reportedly has the same putative parentage as the older name C. ×viridiflora; further study of its parentage is warranted. Cylindropuntia whipplei also hybridizes with C. leptocaulis.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Cylindropuntia spinosior forms hybrids with C. acanthocarpa var. major, C. arbuscula, C. fulgida (see 6. C. ×kelvinensis), C. leptocaulis (see discussion under 3. C. ×tetracantha), and C. versicolor (= C. ×grantiorum P. V. Heath). Introgression between C. spinosior and C. imbricata occurs in a more or less continuous band from central New Mexico to Chihuahua, Mexico. The hybrids between C. spinosior and C. acanthocarpa var. major are sprawling shrubs with irregular branching pattern and have spine clusters with one or more spines longer than others and fleshy fruits, some with one to few spines per fruit. Chromosome numbers of hybrids are all reported as 2n = 22.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Source FNA vol. 4, p. 111. FNA vol. 4.
Parent taxa Cactaceae > subfam. Opuntioideae > Cylindropuntia Cactaceae > subfam. Opuntioideae > Cylindropuntia
Sibling taxa
C. abyssi, C. acanthocarpa, C. arbuscula, C. bigelovii, C. californica, C. davisii, C. echinocarpa, C. fulgida, C. ganderi, C. imbricata, C. kleiniae, C. leptocaulis, C. munzii, C. prolifera, C. ramosissima, C. spinosior, C. tunicata, C. versicolor, C. wolfii, C. ×kelvinensis, C. ×tetracantha
C. abyssi, C. acanthocarpa, C. arbuscula, C. bigelovii, C. californica, C. davisii, C. echinocarpa, C. fulgida, C. ganderi, C. imbricata, C. kleiniae, C. leptocaulis, C. munzii, C. prolifera, C. ramosissima, C. tunicata, C. versicolor, C. whipplei, C. wolfii, C. ×kelvinensis, C. ×tetracantha
Synonyms Opuntia whipplei, C. hualpaensis, C. whipplei var. enodis, Opuntia whipplei var. enodis, Opuntia whipplei var. laevior Opuntia whipplei var. spinosior, Opuntia spinosior, Opuntia spinosior var. neomexicana
Name authority (Engelmann & J. M. Bigelow) F. M. Knuth: in C. Backeberg and F. M. Knuth, Kaktus-ABC, 124. (1935) (Engelmann) F. M. Knuth: in C. Backeberg and F. M. Knuth, Kaktus-ABC, 126. (1935)
Web links