The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

cob cactus, white-column foxtail cactus

beehive cactus, pincushion cactus, spinystar

Habit Plants usually branched and small stemmed (to 50 branches), sometimes unbranched and large stemmed, corncob-like or pinecone-like on below-ground portion, on above-ground portion only on oldest plants, distal portion of stem ± obscured by spines. Plants usually unbranched or with age in some populations to 30 branches, most branches of largest clumps often immature, stems usually stiff and erect, smooth in immature plants to sparsely and coarsely needle-covered in adult plants.
Roots

± diffuse.

± diffuse, less than 1/4 of stem diam.

Stems

ovoid to cylindric (spheric), 4–16 × (2.2–)3–6(–6.5) cm;

tubercles (6–)8–11 × 3–6 mm, firm;

areolar glands absent;

parenchyma not mucilaginous;

druses in pith and cortex nearly microscopic, mostly spheric;

pith 1/8–1/4 of lesser stem diam.;

medullary vascular system absent.

usually more than 1/2 above ground (sometimes deep-seated and flat-topped in winter, in cold climates and/or in immaturity), oblate, spheric, ovoid, obovoid, or cylindric with age, 2.5–20 × 3–11 cm;

tubercles 8–25 × 3–8 mm, stiff or ± flaccid;

areolar glands absent;

parenchyma not mucilaginous (except possibly in far north);

druses in pith and cortex present, some large, 0.7–1 mm diam., lenticular, usually conspicuous in old parts of stem;

pith 1/5–2/3 of lesser stem diam.;

medullary vascular system present.

Spines

(17–)21–41 per areole, ashy white, gray, or pale tan, tips of largest spines pinkish tan to reddish brown or reddish black, all straight;

radial spines 15–41 per areole, gray, (5–)7–12(–13.5) mm, largest spines 0.1–0.2 mm diam.;

subcentral spines 0–6 per areole;

central spines usually 5;

outer central spines (1–)3(–7) per areole, erect or ascending;

inner central spines (0–)2 per areole, porrect or descending, longest spines (5–)10–15(–18) × 0.2–0.3(–0.5) mm.

11–55 per areole;

radial spines 10–40 per areole, weakly appressed or tightly appressed, pectinately arranged in subadults of some populations, either bright white, ashy white, pale tan, pale pinkish gray, or reddish brown (rarely stramineous), tips dark bright pinkish brown, reddish brown, dark brown, orange-brown, or pinkish orange on all or only largest spines (dark tips rarely absent), 7–22 × 0.08–0.6 mm;

subcentral spines sometimes present in adaxial parts of clusters;

central spines straight, snowy white, ashy white, reddish brown, sepia, purplish gray, pinkish gray, brownish red, pinkish brown, horn colored, pale tan, dark purplish brown, or stramineous, opaque or vitreous, fading, then blackening with age;

outer central spines 3–14 per areole;

inner central spines (0–)1(–4) per areole, appressed or strongly projecting, in “bird’s-foot” arrangement or radiating like spokes, longest spines 9–25 × 0.2–0.7 mm.

Flowers

apical or nearly so, (18–)20–30(–32) × 20–45(–4) mm, sterile distal part of flower tube 5–8.5(–11) mm, longer than stamen-bearing part;

outer tepals conspicuously fringed;

inner tepals 21 per flower, pure white, pale rose-pink, or pale lavender-pink, darker centrally, midstripes ± inconspicuous, (9–)11–19 × 1.5–2.5(–3.5) mm;

outer filaments cream;

anthers pale yellow or nearly white;

stigma lobes 4–6(–8), white, (1.8–)2–4 mm.

slightly subapical, 20–57 × 25–67(–90?) mm;

outer tepals conspicuously fringed;

inner tepals 21–56 per flower, usually spreading, recurved, pale rose-pink to reddish pink or magenta, sometimes with darker midstripes, sometimes shading to white or pale greenish, proximally magenta, often darkest distally, 15–35 × 1.3–6 mm;

outer filaments magenta or basally white (rarely entirely white or greenish white), seldom contrasting with inner tepals and, if so, then paler;

anthers bright dark yellow (rarely orange-yellow);

stigma lobes 5–13, erect or ascending, white to magenta, 2.5–5.5 mm.

Fruits

bright red [green to maroon], ellipsoid, cylindric, or narrowly obovoid, (8–)13–25 × 3.5–6.5(–7.5) mm, not very succulent;

floral remnant strongly persistent.

green, exposed portions slowly turning dull brownish red, ovoid to obovoid, 12–28 × 7–20 mm, juicy;

floral remnant persistent.

Seeds

reddish brown, darker with age, obliquely obovoid, 0.9–1 mm, pitted.

bright reddish brown, comma-shaped or nearly obovoid, (1–)1.3–2.4(–3) mm, pitted.

2n

= 22 (as C. strobiliformis, C. varicolor, and Escobaria tuberculosa).

= 22.

Coryphantha tuberculosa

Coryphantha vivipara

Phenology Flowering (Apr-)May–Aug; fruiting Jul–Oct. Flowering spring–late summer (Apr–Aug); fruiting 2-5 months after flowering.
Habitat Stony grasslands, oak-juniper savannas, Larrea scrub, often with Agave lechuguilla, limestone mountainsides or igneous rocks and novaculite Desert scrub to conifer forest, mostly low hills or mountaintops, diverse substrates
Elevation 500-1800(-2200) m (1600-5900(-7200) ft) 200-2700 m (700-8900 ft)
Distribution
from FNA
NM; TX; Mexico (Chihuahua, Coahuila, Durango)
from FNA
AZ; CA; CO; KS; MN; MT; ND; NE; NM; NV; OK; SD; TX; UT; WY; AB; MB; SK; Mexico (Chihuahua, Coahuila, Sonora)
Discussion

The names Coryphantha strobiliformis and Escobaria strobiliformis have been misapplied to C. tuberculosa by some recent authors (e.g., L. D. Benson 1982). Those names were based on Echinocactus strobiliformis Poselger, which is C. chihuahuensis (Britton & Rose) A. Berger.

Despite strong superficial similarity to other species in the genus, Coryphantha tuberculosa seems taxonomically isolated. Coryphantha tuberculosa superficially resembles C. sneedii, from which it is distinguished by (1) giant lenticular druses absent (abundant in older pith and cortex of C. sneedii); (2) fruits in region of sympatry always red (green in most U.S. populations of C. sneedii); (3) maximal expansion of flowers in late afternoon, sometimes remaining fully open at sunset (unlike any other species of Coryphantha); (4) flowers larger than those of C. sneedii, either pure white or a characteristic shade of pale lavender-pink, identifiable at a glance when flowers are alive and open; (5) anthers pale yellow, nearly white (bright yellow in C. sneedii); and (6) sterile distal part of receptacular tube longer than the stamen-bearing portion (short in C. sneedii).

On igneous and metamorphic substrates populations of Coryphantha tuberculosa mostly have unbranched stems. D. Weniger (1984) considered such populations to represent C. varicolor Tiegel; their reproductive structures, however, are identical to those of C. tuberculosa. Without seeds or flowers, mature specimens from such populations sometimes are indistinguishable from C. dasyacantha [hence the synonym C. dasyacantha var. varicolor (Tiegel) L. D. Benson].

Coryphantha tuberculosa is the type species of the segregate genus Escobaria, which includes the coryphanthas with pitted seeds.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Coryphantha vivipara is the most widespread, abundant and variable member of the genus, but it is rare in Mexico. Reports of it from Oregon, Idaho, and northern Utah are incorrect (A. D. Zimmerman 1985).

In the northwestern part of its range, Coryphantha vivipara may occur with Pediocactus simpsonii, which differs in seed color and texture, fruit dehiscence and succulence, and location of flowers/fruits on the plant; sterile material may be distinguished by spine and bract characteristics.

Coryphantha vivipara flowers are virtually identical to those of C. macromeris and Mammillaria wrightii; in the absence of vegetative material, flowers may be unidentifiable. Some unrelated species, such as C. echinus, vegetatively resemble C. vivipara, but those particular species usually have (1) some of the central spines slightly curved, (2) a few areolar glands present, or (3) no medullary vascular system. The large lenticular druses (to 1 mm wide) in the pith and cortex of C. vivipara are shared only with C. sneedii.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Source FNA vol. 4. FNA vol. 4.
Parent taxa Cactaceae > subfam. Cactoideae > Coryphantha Cactaceae > subfam. Cactoideae > Coryphantha
Sibling taxa
C. alversonii, C. chaffeyi, C. chlorantha, C. dasyacantha, C. duncanii, C. echinus, C. hesteri, C. macromeris, C. minima, C. missouriensis, C. nickelsiae, C. ramillosa, C. recurvata, C. robbinsorum, C. robertii, C. robustispina, C. sneedii, C. sulcata, C. vivipara
C. alversonii, C. chaffeyi, C. chlorantha, C. dasyacantha, C. duncanii, C. echinus, C. hesteri, C. macromeris, C. minima, C. missouriensis, C. nickelsiae, C. ramillosa, C. recurvata, C. robbinsorum, C. robertii, C. robustispina, C. sneedii, C. sulcata, C. tuberculosa
Synonyms Mamillaria tuberculosa, C. dasyacantha var. varicolor, C. varicolor, Escobaria dasyacantha var. varicolor, Escobaria tuberculosa Cactus viviparus, C. missouriensis var. marstonii, C. vivipara var. arizonica, C. vivipara var. bisbeeana, C. vivipara var. kaibabensis, C. vivipara var. neomexicana, C. vivipara var. radiosa, C. vivipara var. rosea, Escobaria vivipara
Name authority (Engelmann) A. Berger: Kakteen, 280. (1929) (Nuttall) Britton & Rose: in N. L. Britton and A. Brown, Ill. Fl. N. U.S., ed. 2, 2: 571. (1913)
Web links