FNA: Circaea vs. Onagraceae tribe Circaeeae

Distribution

North America; Europe; Asia; n Africa

North America; Mexico; Central America; South America; West Indies (Hispaniola); Eurasia; n Africa; Pacific Islands (New Zealand, Society Islands)

Discussion

Species 8 (3, including 1 hybrid, in the flora).

Circaea occurs throughout the temperate and boreal northern hemisphere, but is most diverse in eastern Asia, where all but one species occur. Reproductive features include: self-compatible; flowers diurnal, outcrossing, and pollinated by syrphid flies and small bees, or, sometimes, autogamous. It is found in rich, moist soils in deciduous forests and thickets, forest margins, and in moss or soil in mixed, coniferous-broadleaved deciduous, boreal forests. Circaea alpina subsp. alpina and C. canadensis subsp. canadensis often grow in close proximity and hybridize in eastern North America to produce C. ×sterilis. The unilocular C. alpina, with petals less than 2 mm, is self-pollinating under adverse weather conditions, but outcrosses on warm, sunny days. Because of its shorter style and much smaller pollen grains, it is probably the pollen recipient during hybridization events. Artificial hybridization experiments in England using C. alpina as the pollen donor and C. lutetiana as the pollen recipient failed to result in offspring, although hybrids were easily produced in the other direction (P. M. Benoit 1966). Recent molecular phylogenetic analysis supported the separation of the C. canadensis complex into two species; C. alpina subsp. pacifica was found to be sister to the remainder of the genus rather than being nested with other members of C. alpina (Xie L. et al. 2009). Thus, despite the strong morphological similarities of taxa within the C. canadensis and C. alpina complexes, these North American taxa may be better treated as separate species. Further detailed molecular studies are underway to examine this in more detail (Xie et al., unpubl.).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Genera 2, species 117 (2 genera, 4 species, including 1 hybrid, in the flora).

All previous classification systems have placed Circaea and Fuchsia into different tribes, based on their morphological and geographical differences. Molecular analyses place these genera into a single clade (C. J. Bult and E. A. Zimmer 1993; E. Conti et al. 1993; R. A. Levin et al. 2003, 2004; V. S. Ford and L. D. Gottlieb 2007) that is as or more strongly supported than are other clades. The two genera share the feature of indehiscent fruits, expressed in Fuchsia as fleshy berries and in Circaea as dry fruits covered with hooklike hairs; nonhomologous indehiscent fruits also occur in Onagreae. The only occurrences of protogyny in the family occur in these two genera (not in all species of either, P. H. Raven 1979).

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key

1. Flowers opening before elongation of raceme axis, clustered and corymbiform at apex of raceme, on ascending to erect pedicels; capsules clavoid, without corky ribs or grooves; stolons terminated by a tuber.	C. alpina
1. Flowers opening after elongation of raceme axis, more or less loosely spaced, borne on spreading pedicels; capsules usually obovoid to pyriform or subglobose, rarely clavoid, with corky, thickened ribs with deep grooves, or fruit sterile and aborting shortly after anthesis; stolons without or with a terminal tuber.	→ 2
2. Ovaries all or nearly all developing to maturity; capsules with corky thickened ribs separated by deep grooves; pollen highly fertile (greater than 80%); stolons without a tuber.	C. canadensis
2. Ovaries aborting shortly after anthesis, very rarely a few persistent, but easily detached, after anthesis; capsules, when somewhat persistent, smooth or with only low ribs and with shallow grooves; pollen highly sterile (less than 2% fertile); stolons terminated by a tuber or, more commonly, apex sligltly dilated.	C. ×sterilis