Flora of North America species comparison

The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Chylismia claviformis

Chylismia parryi
Chylismia claviformis

brown-eyed primrose, browneyes, clavate fruit primrose

redclay suncup
Habit Herbs annual, glabrous, strigillose, glandular puberulent, or, sometimes, villous. Herbs annual, sparsely to densely villous throughout or, sometimes, glabrate distally.
Stems

branched mostly from base, 3–70 cm.

often intricately branched, 5–80 cm.
Leaves

primarily in basal rosette, cauline reduced or absent, 1.5–20 × 0.3–3.5 cm;

petiole 0.7–12 cm;

blade usually pinnately lobed, sometimes lateral lobes poorly developed or absent, terminal lobe usually narrowly ovate to lanceolate, sometimes cordate or subcordate, 0.8–9 × 0.2–4.5 cm, margins dentate, sinuate-dentate, or serrate, brown oil cells conspicuously lining veins abaxially.

in poorly defined basal rosette and also cauline;

petiole 0.3–3.8 cm;

blade usually unlobed, very rarely pinnately lobed with few, small lateral lobes, ovate to elliptic, margins sparsely denticulate to subentire, pale or dark brown oil cells lining veins abaxially.
Racemes

nodding, elongating after anthesis.

nodding, with intricate, filiform branches, elongating in fruit.
Flowers

opening at sunset or sunrise;

buds with or without subapical or apical free tips;

floral tube 2–6.5 mm, villous inside proximally;

sepals 2–8 mm;

petals pale to bright yellow or white, sometimes red- or purple-dotted near base, fading purple, sometimes red or orange, or not changing color, 1.5–8 mm;

stamens subequal, filaments 1.5–5.5 mm, anthers 1.5–6 mm, ciliate;

style 5–16 mm, stigma exserted beyond anthers at anthesis.

opening at sunrise;

buds without free tips;

floral tube 0.5–2 mm, glabrous or villous inside;

sepals 1.5–4 mm;

petals bright yellow, often with red dots near base, fading pale yellow or yellowish orange, 2–7 mm;

stamens unequal, filaments of antisepalous stamens 1.7–3.5 mm, those of antipetalous ones 1.2–2.5 mm, anthers 0.9–1.2 mm, glabrous;

style 4–9 mm, stigma exserted beyond anthers at anthesis.
Capsules

ascending to spreading, clavate, 8–40 mm;

pedicel 4–40 mm.

erect or ascending, clavate, 4–10 mm;

pedicel 4–20 mm.
Seeds

0.6–1.5 mm.

0.7–1.2 mm.
2n

= 14.

Chylismia claviformis

Chylismia parryi
Phenology Flowering May–Jun(–Sep).
Habitat Red clay and sand slopes weathered from red (freshwater-deposited) sandstone cliffs, with Juniperus or Larrea tridentata.
Elevation 800–1300 m. [2600–4300 ft.]
Distribution
w United States; nw Mexico
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
AZ; UT
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Subspecies 11 (10 in the flora).

P. H. Raven (1962) subdivided this species into 12 subspecies and, subsequently (1969), he combined two of them. The latter approach is used here. Only subsp. wigginsii P. H. Raven does not occur in the United States; its narrow range is restricted to northern Baja California. Raven (1962, 1969) determined this species to be self-incompatible.

Chylismia claviformis is the most complex and, along with C. scapoidea, the most widely distributed species of the genus. The central part of its geographical range is occupied by five closely related white-petaled subspecies (aurantiaca, claviformis, funerea, integrior, and peeblesii) that are very similar morphologically. South of this area four additional subspecies occur, all yellow-petaled (peirsonii, rubescens, wigginsii, and yumae). These four subspecies have sepals and petal color similar to those of C. brevipes, and P. H. Raven (1962, 1969) thought it likely that they were derived following hybridization between that species and one of the white-petaled populations of C. claviformis. North of the range of the white-petaled subspecies are found two additional yellow-petaled subspecies (cruciformis and lancifolia). Most populations of subsp. cruciformis consist of plants in which the flowers open in the early morning; in all other subspecies the flowers open in the late afternoon (Raven 1962, 1969). The following key will separate them, but there are many intergrades among the subspecies so that not all specimens will be easily identified.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Chylismia parryi is known from northwestern Arizona (Coconino to Mohave counties) and southwestern Utah (Beaver to Washington counties), and is apparently disjunct to San Juan County, Utah. It is outcrossing and, perhaps, self-incompatible (P. H. Raven 1962, 1969). There are two morphological forms of this species. Raven (1962) noted that a later flowering form has narrower, smaller leaves, and less overall pubescence. It is not clear what these represent, but Raven (1962) made the combination Oenothera parryi forma tenuissima (M. E. Jones) P. H. Raven for it. He later (Raven 1969) noted that these plants did not seem to merit formal recognition, without any discussion.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)
Key
1. Herbs villous proximally; buds with subapical free tips; petals usually yellow, rarely white.
→ 2
2. Petals not changing color in fading, 4.5–7 mm; lateral lobes of leaf blades well developed.
subsp. peirsonii
2. Petals fading brick red, 3–5 mm; lateral lobes of leaf blades poorly developed, small or absent.
subsp. rubescens
1. Herbs strigillose, glandular puberulent, or glabrous proximally; buds with or without subapical or apical free tips; petals yellow or white.
→ 3
3. Petals yellow.
→ 4
4. Herbs strigillose, sometimes also glandular puberulent distally.
subsp. yumae
4. Herbs glabrous or glandular puberulent distally.
→ 5
5. Leaf blades with narrowly ovate to subcordate terminal lobes, at least some lateral lobes developed; flowers usually opening at dawn.
subsp. cruciformis
5. Leaf blades with lanceolate terminal lobes, lateral lobes usually greatly reduced or absent; flowers usually opening at dusk.
subsp. lancifolia
3. Petals usually white, rarely pale yellow (in subsp. claviformis).
→ 6
6. Herbs usually glabrous distally, rarely sparsely strigillose or glandular puberulent; lateral lobes of leaf blades usually well developed.
subsp. claviformis
6. Herbs usually strigillose and/or glandular puberulent, rarely glabrate; lateral lobes of leaf blades reduced, absent, or well developed.
→ 7
7. Lateral lobes of leaf blades well developed.
→ 8
8. Herbs strigillose, sometimes glabrate distally.
subsp. aurantiaca
8. Herbs glandular puberulent and strigillose.
subsp. peeblesii
7. Lateral lobes of leaf blades poorly developed, small, or absent.
→ 9
9. Leaf blades usually with at least some poorly developed lateral lobes; plants strigillose.
subsp. funerea
9. Leaf blades often with only terminal lobe developed; plants strigillose proximally, strigil-lose and glandular puberulent or glabrate distally.
subsp. integrior
Source FNA vol. 10. Treatment author: Warren L. Wagner. FNA vol. 10. Treatment author: Warren L. Wagner.
Parent taxa Onagraceae > subfam. Onagroideae > tribe Onagreae > Chylismia > sect. Chylismia Onagraceae > subfam. Onagroideae > tribe Onagreae > Chylismia > sect. Chylismia
Sibling taxa
C. arenaria, C. atwoodii, C. brevipes, C. cardiophylla, C. confertiflora, C. eastwoodiae, C. exilis, C. heterochroma, C. megalantha, C. multijuga, C. munzii, C. parryi, C. scapoidea, C. specicola, C. walkeri
C. arenaria, C. atwoodii, C. brevipes, C. cardiophylla, C. claviformis, C. confertiflora, C. eastwoodiae, C. exilis, C. heterochroma, C. megalantha, C. multijuga, C. munzii, C. scapoidea, C. specicola, C. walkeri
Subordinate taxa
C. claviformis subsp. aurantiaca, C. claviformis subsp. claviformis, C. claviformis subsp. cruciformis, C. claviformis subsp. funerea, C. claviformis subsp. integrior, C. claviformis subsp. lancifolia, C. claviformis subsp. peeblesii, C. claviformis subsp. peirsonii, C. claviformis subsp. rubescens, C. claviformis subsp. yumae
Synonyms Oenothera claviformis, Camissonia claviformis, C. scapoidea var. claviformis, O. scapoidea var. claviformis Oenothera parryi, Camissonia parryi, C. tenuissima, O. scapoidea var. parryi, O. tenuissima
Name authority (Torrey & Frémont) A. Heller: Muhlenbergia 2: 105. (1906) — (as Chylisma clavaeformis) (S. Watson) Small: Bull. Torrey Bot. Club 23: 193. (1896) — (as Chylisma)
Web links 
Unless otherwise noted, all data comes from the online version of the Flora of North America, who have made most of their content available via a Creative Commons license (CC BY 4.0).



Type/paste one or more Latin names into the boxes above; matching taxa will show up below the box as you type. You can use the up/down arrow keys to move through the list.

(If the plant you're looking for doesn't show up in the auto-complete list, that means it either isn't described in Flora of North America yet, or it's listed under a synonym. And please note that Flora of North America is still missing several plant families, including Apiaceae, Boraginaceae, and Polemoniaceae.)

The species comparison tool is brought to you by:
Northwest Wildflowers