The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

Thurber's needlegrass, Thurber's rice grass

Parish's needlegrass

Habit Plants cespitose, not rhizomatous. Plants tightly cespitose, not rhizomatous.
Culms

30-75 cm tall, 0.5-1.7 mm thick, internodes pubescent or glabrous, pubescence more common on the lower internodes, particularly just below the nodes;

nodes 2-3, lower nodes retrorsely pubescent, upper nodes glabrous or pubescent.

14-80 cm tall, 0.8-2 mm thick, internodes glabrous or pubescent below the nodes;

nodes 3-5, glabrous.

Panicles

7-15 cm long, 0.5-2.5 cm wide, often included in the upper leaf sheaths at the start of anthesis;

branches 1.5-6 cm, appressed to strongly ascending, with 1-6 spikelets.

7-15 cm long, 1.5-4 cm wide;

branches strongly ascending at maturity, longest branches 1.5-4 cm.

Glumes

often purplish;

lower glumes 10-15 mm long, 1.2-2 mm wide;

upper glumes to 2 mm shorter;

florets 6-9 mm long, 0.7-1.2 mm thick, fusiform, terete;

calluses 0.9-1.5 mm, sharp;

lemmas coriaceous, evenly pubescent or the back glabrate distally, hairs 0.5-0.8 mm, apices lobed on 1 margin, lobe about 0.1 mm long, thick, apical lemma hairs 0.5-0.8 mm;

awns 32-56 mm, twice-geniculate, first 2 segments pilose, hairs 0.8-2 mm, terminal segment glabrous, often scabrous;

paleas 4.6-6.1 mm, 3/4 - 9/10 as long as the lemmas, sparsely pubescent towards the base;

anthers 2.5-3.5 mm, dehiscent, not penicillate.

unequal to subequal, narrowly lanceolate, 3-5-veined;

lower glumes 9-15 mm long, 0.9-1.2 mm wide;

upper glumes 8-15 mm;

florets 4.8-6.5 mm long, 0.8-1 mm thick, fusiform, terete;

calluses 0.2-0.8 mm, acute;

lemmas evenly and densely hairy, hairs 1.5-3.5 mm at midlength, apical hairs 2.5-5 mm;

awns 10-35 mm, persistent, once-geniculate, first segment scabrous or strigose, hairs to 0.3 mm, terminal segment straight;

paleas 2.5-4.5 mm, 1/2 - 4/5 times the length of the lemmas, hairy between the veins, hairs often as long as those on the lemmas but not as dense, apices usually rounded, occasionally somewhat pinched;

anthers 2.3-4.5 mm, dehiscent, not penicillate.

Caryopses

5-7 mm, fusiform.

3-6 mm, fusiform.

Basal

sheaths glabrous, usually smooth, brown or gray-brown;

collars glabrous, without tufts of hair at the sides;

basal ligules 1.5-6 mm, hyaline, rounded to acute, lacerate;

upper ligules to 8 mm, hyaline, acute, glabrous;

blades 0.5-2 mm wide, convolute, abaxial surfaces scabrous, adaxial surfaces scabrous or hairy, hairs about 0.3 mm.

sheaths mostly glabrous, sometimes pubescent at the base, flat and ribbonlike with age, margins sometimes hairy distally, hairs adjacent to the ligules 0.5-3 mm;

collars glabrous;

ligules truncate, abaxial surfaces pubescent, ciliate, cilia as long as or longer than the basal membrane, ligules of basal leaves 0.3-0.8 mm, of upper leaves 0.5-1.5 mm, asymmetric;

blades 4-30+ cm long, 1-4.2 mm wide, usually flat and more or less straight, sometimes tightly convolute and arcuate.

2n

=34.

= unknown.

Achnatherum thurberianum

Achnatherum parishii

Distribution
from FNA
CA; CO; ID; MT; NV; OR; UT; WA; WY
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
from FNA
AZ; CA; NV; UT
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Achnatherum thurberianum grows in canyons and foothills, primarily in sagebrush desert and juniper woodland associations, from Washington to southern Idaho and southwestern Montana and from California to Utah, at 900-3000 m. Its long ligules and pilose awns make it one of the easier North American species of Achnatherum to identify.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Achnatherum parishii grows from the coastal ranges of California to Nevada and Utah, south to Baja California, Mexico, and to the Grand Canyon in Arizona. It differs from A. coronatum in its once-geniculate awns, more densely pubescent paleas, and generally smaller stature; from A. scribneri in its shorter, blunter calluses and more abundant lemma hairs; and from A. perplexum in having longer hairs on its lemmas.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key
1. Basal sheath margins glabrous or hairy distaily, hairs to 0.5 mm long; culms 14-35 cm tall
subsp. depauperatum
1. Basal sheath margins hairy distaily, hairs 1-3.2 mm long; culms 20-80 cm tall
subsp. parishii
Source FNA vol. 24, p. 125. FNA vol. 24, p. 127.
Parent taxa Poaceae > subfam. Pooideae > tribe Stipeae > Achnatherum Poaceae > subfam. Pooideae > tribe Stipeae > Achnatherum
Sibling taxa
A. aridum, A. arnowiae, A. contractum, A. coronatum, A. curvifolium, A. diegoense, A. eminens, A. hendersonii, A. hymenoides, A. latiglume, A. lemmonii, A. lettermanii, A. lobatum, A. nelsonii, A. nevadense, A. occidentale, A. parishii, A. perplexum, A. pinetorum, A. richardsonii, A. robustum, A. scribneri, A. splendens, A. stillmanii, A. swallenii, A. wallowaense, A. webberi, A. ×bloomeri
A. aridum, A. arnowiae, A. contractum, A. coronatum, A. curvifolium, A. diegoense, A. eminens, A. hendersonii, A. hymenoides, A. latiglume, A. lemmonii, A. lettermanii, A. lobatum, A. nelsonii, A. nevadense, A. occidentale, A. perplexum, A. pinetorum, A. richardsonii, A. robustum, A. scribneri, A. splendens, A. stillmanii, A. swallenii, A. thurberianum, A. wallowaense, A. webberi, A. ×bloomeri
Subordinate taxa
A. parishii subsp. depauperatum, A. parishii subsp. parishii
Synonyms Stipa thurberiana Stipa parishii
Name authority (Piper) Barkworth (Vasey) Barkworth
Web links