The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

musk thistle, nodding thistle

Italian plumeless thistle

Habit Biennial herb 3-25 dm. tall, the stem winged from the leaf bases. Annuals, 20-200 cm in total height, stems simple to openly branched, loosely tomentose with fine single-celled hairs and sessile growths with curled, septate hairs; teeth of wings up to 10 mm, wing spines to 20 mm.
Leaves

Leaves deeply lobed, up to 40 cm. long and 15 cm. wide, mostly glabrous.

Basal leaves tapering to winged petioles, blades 10–25 cm, margins pinnately 2 to 5 lobed, abaxial faces ± tomentose, adaxial faces tomentose and pilose, often glabrate;

cauline leaves sessile, shorter, margins less divided than basal, distally reduced to bracts.

Flowers

Heads mostly solitary and nodding at the ends of the branches, the disk usually 4-8 cm. wide; middle and outer involucre bracts broad, 2-8 mm. wide, with long, flat, spiny tip, the mid-rib very prominent; inner bracts narrower and softer, often purplish;

flowers purple;

pappus capillary, not plumose.

Heads borne singly or clustered in tight groups of 2-5, heads at ends of branches and sometimes in upper axils, sessile or short-pedunculate, 20–25 mm;

peduncles winged throughout or unwinged, 0–2 cm long, tomentose;

involucres cylindric to ellipsoid, 17–22 mm diameter;

phyllaries linear to lanceolate, with appressed loosely tomentose bases, 2–3 mm wide and ascending, linear appendages 0.5–1.5 mm wide, not scarious, distally scabrous on midribs and margins, spine tips 1–3 mm, inner straight and erect, with unarmed or minutely armed tips;

Corollas purple, dark purple, or pink, 14–16 mm long tube;

lobes 3 times longer than throat.

Fruit(s)

Achenes glabrous.

Cypselae ellipsoid, golden to brown, 4–6 mm, finely 20-nerved;

pappus bristles 15–20 mm.

Carduus nutans

Carduus pycnocephalus

Flowering time June-October June-July
Habitat Roadsides, fields, ditches, wastelots, and other disturbed, open areas. Disturbed, open areas at low elevation.
Distribution
Occurring in scattered locations on both sides of the Cascades crest in Washington; British Columbia to California, east to the Atlantic Coast.
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Occurring west of the Cascades crest in Washington, where known only from Clallam County; Washington to California and Idaho, also in central and eastern U.S.
[WildflowerSearch map]
[BONAP county map]
Origin Introduced from Eurasia Introduced from Europe
Conservation status Not of concern Not of concern
Sibling taxa
C. acanthoides, C. pycnocephalus, C. tenuiflorus
C. acanthoides, C. nutans, C. tenuiflorus
Subordinate taxa
C. pycnocephalus ssp. pycnocephalus
Web links